Part 4: A system, mistakes and test · Chapter 13 of 14 · 9 min

An Elliott and Fibonacci system under test

Entry on wave 2 at 50% or 61.8% of wave 1, stop below the start, target at the end of wave 1 or wave 3 at 100% or 161.8%: 6 variants on 211 gold legs, mean R from −0.28 to −0.03, always below random entries with the same geometry (from +0.01 to +0.14). With hindsight the same legs give +1.36 R.

The system

The only way to use Elliott in real time is to enter on wave 2 to ride wave 3, so:

  • Wave 1: a leg A → B (H4 swings of at least 2 ATR, B confirmed two candles later).
  • Entry (wave 2): limit order at the level e of wave 1 (50% or 61.8%), in the direction of wave 1. Valid for 40 candles; it lapses if a candle closes beyond A.
  • Stop: beyond A by 0.25 ATR (rule 1 says that below A the count is refuted). Risk between 0.5 and 3 ATR, otherwise the trade is skipped.
  • Target (wave 3): the end of wave 1 (B), or wave 3 = 100% or 161.8% of wave 1, measured from the entry.
  • Exit: 60 candles after the fill. Cost 0.30 $ per ounce.

The 211 H4 gold legs (December 2025 - October 2026) give, for the 61.8%, 144 trades (44 orders never filled, 23 skipped for risk).

The result

Mean R with the 95% interval, and the comparison with random entries: same stop and target distance in dollars, but random candle and direction (2,000 trials).

Level and targetTradesMean RWinnersTarget (in R)Random entries: median (5th-95th)Random trials with R at least equal
50%, end of wave 1129−0.25 ± 0.1640%0.86−0.03 (−0.16 / +0.10)100%
50%, wave 3 = 100%129−0.28 ± 0.2028%1.72+0.05 (−0.13 / +0.24)100%
50%, wave 3 = 161.8%129−0.21 ± 0.2525%2.79+0.11 (−0.12 / +0.34)99%
61.8%, end of wave 1144−0.12 ± 0.1938%1.35+0.01 (−0.14 / +0.17)92%
61.8%, wave 3 = 100%144−0.17 ± 0.2227%2.19+0.07 (−0.13 / +0.27)98%
61.8%, wave 3 = 161.8%144−0.03 ± 0.2924%3.55+0.14 (−0.12 / +0.39)85%

None of the 6 variants is positive: the best (61.8% with a 161.8% target) makes −0.03 ± 0.29. Random entries with the same geometry give between −0.03 and +0.14 R, and the system sits below most of the trials (from 85% to 100%). Part of the gap comes from the mechanism of the limit order: the order fills when price is moving against the position, and the same effect is in books 2-4. The 161.8% of wave 1 corresponds on average to 3.55 times the risk: 22% winners would be needed to break even, the winners are 24% and the result stays at −0.03 R.

Splitting the period, for the 61.8%: with target B the first half gives −0.10 ± 0.27 (71 trades) and the second −0.15 ± 0.26 (73); with wave 3 = 100% −0.23 ± 0.31 and −0.12 ± 0.33; with 161.8% −0.05 ± 0.41 and 0.00 ± 0.42.

Figure 1 shows a winning trade with a 161.8% target: wave 1 from 4,601.50 to 4,703.87 $ (6 April 2026), order at 61.8% at 4,640.61 $ filled on 7 April at 00:00, stop at 4,597.20 $, target at 4,806.24 $ (3.82 times the risk) reached on 7 April at 20:00: +3.81 R. Figure 2 shows a loss: wave 1 from 4,652.74 to 4,505.00 $, order at 4,596.30 $ filled on 5 May at 20:00, stop at 4,657.91 $ hit on 6 May at 04:00: −1.00 R (target at 4,357.26 $, 3.88 times the risk).

Figure 1. Wave 1 from 4,601.50 to 4,703.87, order at 61.8% at 4,640.61, target at 161.8% of wave 1 (4,806.24) reached on 7 April: +3.81 R.Data: gold, XAUUSDT perpetual future (real candles) · 4 hours (H4) · from 5 Apr 2026 12:00 UTC to 8 Apr 2026 08:00 UTC.
Read the chart in words

H4 gold chart from 5 to 8 April 2026 with points 0 and 1 of wave 1, the entry line, the stop line (4,597.20) and the target line (4,806.24).

WhenWhatPrice
6 Apr 2026 00:00 UTCPoint 04,601.50
6 Apr 2026 08:00 UTCPoint 14,703.87
7 Apr 2026 00:00 UTCEntry (61.8%)4,640.61
7 Apr 2026 00:00 UTCStop4,597.20
7 Apr 2026 00:00 UTCTarget 161.8%4,806.24
7 Apr 2026 20:00 UTCtarget reached4,833.73

Times in UTC.

Figure 2. Wave 1 from 4,652.74 to 4,505.00, order at 61.8% at 4,596.30, stop at 4,657.91 hit on 6 May: −1.00 R (target at 4,357.26).Data: gold, XAUUSDT perpetual future (real candles) · 4 hours (H4) · from 3 May 2026 08:00 UTC to 6 May 2026 16:00 UTC.
Read the chart in words

H4 gold chart from 3 to 6 May 2026 with points 0 and 1 of wave 1, the entry line, the stop line (4,657.91) and the target line (4,357.26).

WhenWhatPrice
3 May 2026 20:00 UTCPoint 04,652.74
4 May 2026 16:00 UTCPoint 14,505.00
5 May 2026 20:00 UTCEntry (61.8%)4,596.30
5 May 2026 20:00 UTCStop4,657.91
5 May 2026 20:00 UTCTarget 161.8%4,357.26
6 May 2026 04:00 UTCstop hit4,682.64

Times in UTC.

The edge of hindsight

Of all the 211 legs, 14 were, afterwards, wave 1 of a valid impulse (chapter 7). If you take only those, with the order at 61.8%:

LegsTradesMean R (target B)Mean R (wave 3 = 100%)
Wave 1 of a valid impulse (14, chosen with hindsight)8+1.36 ± 0.04+2.21 ± 0.06
All the others (197)136−0.21 ± 0.19−0.31 ± 0.22

The result is splendid and worthless: an impulse is valid only after wave 5 is confirmed, five swings after the moment you should enter (in figure 3 the leg from 2 to 3 June 2026 gives an order at 4,498.18 $ filled on 4 June at 08:00, with the stop at 4,550.80 $ and the target at 4,308.03 $ reached on 6 June at 04:00, +3.61 R; the impulse it belongs to completes only on 8 June at 04:00, at 4,271.20 $). In real time you do not know which leg will become an impulse. Selecting trades from the final count is a forecasting error: it uses in the past information that exists only in the future.

Figure 3. A leg that is, afterwards, wave 1 of a valid impulse (grey line, complete on 8 June 2026 at 4,271.20): order at 61.8% at 4,498.18, target at 4,308.03 reached on 6 June (+3.61 R). The complete count does not exist when you must enter.Data: gold, XAUUSDT perpetual future (real candles) · 4 hours (H4) · from 1 Jun 2026 16:00 UTC to 8 Jun 2026 16:00 UTC.
Read the chart in words

H4 gold chart from 1 to 8 June 2026 with the broken line of the valid impulse in dashed grey, points 0 and 1 of wave 1, the entry line, the stop line (4,550.80) and the target line (4,308.03).

WhenWhatPrice
2 Jun 2026 04:00 UTCPoint 04,543.07
3 Jun 2026 20:00 UTCPoint 14,425.55
4 Jun 2026 08:00 UTCEntry (61.8%)4,498.18
4 Jun 2026 08:00 UTCStop4,550.80
4 Jun 2026 08:00 UTCTarget 161.8%4,308.03
6 Jun 2026 04:00 UTCtarget reached4,304.34

Times in UTC.

Procedure in five steps

  1. Write the system with every rule applicable in real time: swing, entry, stop, target, exit, cost.
  2. Count all the legs, including orders never filled and trades skipped.
  3. Compare with random entries with the same stop and target geometry.
  4. Split the period and check that the two halves say the same thing.
  5. Distrust any filter that uses information available only after the trade.

Exercises

Chapter exercises

1. Wave 1 goes from 1,000 to 1,100 (hypothetical numbers). Order at 61.8% at 1,038.20, stop at 1,000 and target at 161.8% of wave 1 from the entry (1,200.00). How many R is the target worth?

2. The system (61.8%, 161.8% target) gives −0.03 ± 0.29 R, and random entries with the same geometry give +0.14 R (5th-95th: −0.12 / +0.39). What can be said?

3. The 14 legs that were wave 1 of a valid impulse give +1.36 R (8 trades) and the others −0.21 R. What is wrong with the comparison?

4. Why does the system sit below random entries with the same geometry?

Have a question or want to share your exercise?

Post in the community, or join the free signals room on Telegram.

Educational content, not financial advice. Trading involves risk.