Part 2: The indicators one by one · Chapter 8 of 14 · 9 min

ADX and trend strength: the 25 threshold does not separate trends

The ADX formula with +DI and −DI, how often it sits above the classic thresholds (above 25 in 62% of candles), what price does afterwards by regime and as a filter for the crossover system: filtering with the ADX the trades fall from 28 to 4 and the total goes from +433 dollars to −358.

The formula

Wilder's ADX (Average Directional Index) measures how much the move goes in one direction, without saying which. It is built in three steps. From the movement of highs and lows you get the positive and negative directional movement and divide them by the ATR: these are +DI and −DI (from 0 to 100). Then DX = 100 × |+DI − −DI| ÷ (+DI + −DI). The 14-period ADX is Wilder's average of the DX. It runs from 0 to 100.

The classic rule: ADX below 20, a market with no direction; above 25, a trend; higher, a stronger trend. +DI above −DI means the upward movement dominates, and the opposite. The ADX level is used to say whether there is a trend, and the DI crossover to say which way.

How often it is in the zone

On H4 the 14-period ADX has a median of 28.8 (10th percentile 17.5, 90th 46.6), with a minimum of 9.6 and a maximum of 67.3. It sits below 20 in 19% of candles, between 20 and 25 in 19%, above 25 in 62% and above 40 in 24%. The 25 threshold, which should separate periods with a trend from those without, is exceeded by almost two candles out of three: on gold, with a wide average move, the ADX is nearly always above it.

Two real cases

Figure 1 shows a period with no direction, on H4, from 15 to 23 September 2026. The ADX sits between 15.3 and 22.4, and the DIs cross eight times in seven days (four upward, four downward): on 16 September at 00:00 (ADX 17.4), at 16:00 (18.4), on 17 September at 00:00 (17.1), then on 21 September at 04:00, 08:00, 12:00 and 20:00 and on 22 September at 04:00 (with ADX between 16.2 and 19.7). Each crossover would be a "signal".

Figure 1. A period with no direction: the ADX stays between 15.3 and 22.4 and the DIs cross eight times in seven days.Data: gold, XAUUSDT perpetual future (real candles) · 4 hours (H4) · from 15 Sept 2026 00:00 UTC to 23 Sept 2026 20:00 UTC.
Read the chart in words

H4 gold chart from 15 to 23 September 2026 and, below, the ADX (black) with +DI (blue) and −DI (dashed pink) and the 20 and 40 levels. Labels mark the eight DI crossovers.

WhenWhatPrice
16 Sept 2026 00:00 UTC+DI above4,346.46
16 Sept 2026 16:00 UTC−DI above4,243.81
17 Sept 2026 00:00 UTC+DI above4,323.21
21 Sept 2026 04:00 UTC−DI above4,346.31
21 Sept 2026 08:00 UTC+DI above4,374.77
21 Sept 2026 12:00 UTC−DI above4,327.11
21 Sept 2026 20:00 UTC+DI above4,374.87
22 Sept 2026 04:00 UTC−DI above4,301.82

Times in UTC.

Figure 2 shows the opposite case, the March collapse, from 16 to 25 March 2026. The ADX reaches 67.3 on 22 March at 16:00 (close $4,487.85, +DI 6.6, −DI 40.4), the maximum of the period. But price had already fallen from 4,933.32 on 18 March to 4,497.25 on 22 March: the ADX peaked when most of the move was done.

Figure 2. The March collapse: the ADX reaches 67.3 on 22 March (close 4,487.85), the maximum of the period, after price had already lost over 400 dollars.Data: gold, XAUUSDT perpetual future (real candles) · 4 hours (H4) · from 16 Mar 2026 00:00 UTC to 25 Mar 2026 04:00 UTC.
Read the chart in words

H4 gold chart from 16 to 25 March 2026 and, below, the ADX (black) with +DI (blue) and −DI (dashed pink) and the 20 and 40 levels. A label marks the ADX maximum.

WhenWhatPrice
22 Mar 2026 16:00 UTCADX 67.34,486.07

Times in UTC.

What the data says

For every candle we look at the net move of the next 10 candles (close to close, in ATR) and whether it goes in the direction of the dominant DI (+DI above = up).

ADXCandlesMean net move (absolute)Goes in the dominant DI's direction
Below 203302.92 ATR (median 1.70)46% ±5
20-253271.98 ATR (median 1.37)45% ±5
25-406472.04 ATR (median 1.18)55% ±4
Above 404172.14 ATR (median 1.36)51% ±5

A high ADX did not precede larger moves (2.0-2.1 ATR) than a low ADX (2.9 ATR): with a low ADX the starting volatility is low and tends to go back toward the norm (chapter 7). The direction of the dominant DI held 55% of the time with an ADX between 25 and 40, against 45-46% with an ADX below 25; with an ADX above 40, 51%. The only difference is between ADX 25-40 and low ADX, and the cases overlap.

The state by regime, with the benchmark (up carries on 36%, down 40%): with ADX ≥ 25 the dominant DI "up" carries on 42% (451 signals) and the "down" one 41% (613); with ADX below 20, 36% and 41%; with ADX between 20 and 25, 32% and 45%. The DI crossover signals: 105 in all. Upward 46% carries on (±14, 52 cases), downward 40% (±13, 53). With ADX ≥ 25 at the crossover: upward 29% (24 cases, ±18), downward 36% (25, ±19); with ADX below 25: 61% upward and 43% downward (28 cases per side, ±18).

The ADX as a filter

The most common way to use it: take a crossover system and enter only if the ADX exceeds a threshold. On the EMA 20/50 system from chapter 2 (always in, cost of 0.30 dollars per ounce; exit at the opposite crossover):

FilterTradesWinningMean per tradeTotal
None289 (32%)+15.47 ± 29.93 dollars+433
ADX ≥ 15258 (32%)+3.42 ± 29.84 dollars+86
ADX ≥ 20206 (30%)−12.55 ± 29.05 dollars−251
ADX ≥ 25113 (27%)−11.65 ± 48.89 dollars−128
ADX ≥ 3040 (0%)−89.61 ± 19.35 dollars−358

The higher the threshold, the fewer trades remain and the more the total worsens: from +433 to −358 dollars per ounce. With 4-25 trades the errors (19-49 dollars) exceed the means, so the worsening is not proven: but the filter improved nothing. The trades are few also because the system has few crossovers: EMA 20/50 crossovers with ADX below 20 number 9, between 20 and 30 number 16 and above 30 number 4.

A four-step routine

  1. Measure how often the ADX sits above the threshold you want to use, in your instrument: on gold 25 is exceeded 62% of the time.
  2. Do not confuse the ADX level (there is a trend) with the direction (the DI says it).
  3. If you use it as a filter, count the trades that remain and compare the total with and without.
  4. Remember that a high ADX arrives after the move is under way.

Exercises

Chapter exercises

1. On the chart the letters sit on four candles, with the ADX below. Which letter is the candle in which the ADX is at its maximum (67.3)?

Chart exercise. Data: gold, XAUUSDT perpetual future (real candles) · 4 hours (H4) · from 16 Mar 2026 00:00 UTC to 25 Mar 2026 04:00 UTC.
Read the chart in words
WhenWhatPrice
20 Mar 2026 16:00 UTCPoint A4,620.00
22 Mar 2026 16:00 UTCPoint B4,495.80
24 Mar 2026 00:00 UTCPoint C4,448.89
16 Mar 2026 08:00 UTCPoint D5,022.99

Times in UTC.

2. What does the ADX measure?

3. On gold the ADX sits above 25 in 62% of candles. What do you take from it for the rule "above 25 there is a trend"?

4. Filtering the EMA 20/50 system with ADX ≥ 25 leaves 11 trades out of 28 and the total is −128 dollars against +433. What do you conclude?

Have a question or want to share your exercise?

Post in the community, or join the free signals room on Telegram.

Educational content, not financial advice. Trading involves risk.