Part 3: Using them together · Chapter 10 of 14 · 8 min
Combining indicators: redundancy
How much eight indicators resemble each other on the same candles (mean correlation 0.81, a single component explains 84% of the variance), what price does afterwards when five indicators vote together and a voting system with cost: the best gives +1,201 dollars per ounce over 71 trades, but it is the best of three thresholds tried.
Why combine
The common idea is that two indicators in agreement are more reliable than one: confluence. It works only if the two indicators carry different information. The indicators of chapters 2-8 are all formulas on the same closes, so the first thing to measure is how much they resemble each other.
How much they resemble each other
On 1,712 H4 candles we compute eight numbers: RSI 14, stochastic %K, CCI 20, the position within the Bollinger bands (%B), the MACD line divided by the ATR, the distance from the EMA 20 and from the EMA 50 divided by the ATR, and the return of the previous 10 candles divided by the ATR. The correlation between pairs, some examples:
| Pair | Correlation |
|---|---|
| RSI and distance from the EMA 20 | 0.98 |
| CCI and band %B | 0.98 |
| RSI and distance from the EMA 50 | 0.96 |
| RSI and MACD | 0.89 |
| RSI and stochastic | 0.80 |
| Stochastic and MACD | 0.65 |
| CCI and MACD | 0.57 |
The mean correlation across all 28 pairs is 0.81 (from 0.57 to 0.98). The first principal component explains 84% of the variance of the eight indicators: eight numbers that, for 84%, say one thing (which way and how much price has moved recently). The correlation of each with the move of the next 10 candles runs from 0.01 to 0.08: none has a strong link with the future.
Figure 1 shows three of them on H4, from 15 to 25 August 2026: RSI, stochastic %K and band %B on the same scale. They rise and fall together: the RSI reaches 82.5 and the %K 98.3 in the same climb.
Read the chart in words
H4 gold chart from 15 to 25 August 2026 and, below, RSI (black), stochastic %K (dashed pink) and Bollinger band %B (blue) on a 0 to 100 scale. The three lines rise and fall together.
How much counting votes helps
We count the "bullish votes" out of five: RSI above 50, %K above 50, CCI above 0, MACD line above 0, close above the EMA 50. With 0 votes all are bearish, with 5 all bullish. We look at which comes first between +1.5 ATR and −1.5 ATR in 10 candles (the benchmark with any candle: up 36%, down 40%).
| Bullish votes | Candles | Up first | Down first | Mean move over 10 candles (ATR) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 531 | 37% | 38% | +0.09 |
| 1 | 177 | 29% | 49% | −0.71 |
| 2 | 132 | 18% | 55% | −1.51 |
| 3 | 156 | 24% | 47% | −0.46 |
| 4 | 152 | 27% | 43% | 0.00 |
| 5 | 553 | 45% | 33% | +0.41 |
With 5 bullish votes price rose first 45% of the time, against 33% down (benchmark 36% and 40%). With 0 votes, all bearish, the result is even (37% and 38%): there was no continuation downward. With 1-4 votes price fell more often, but they are the intermediate states and depend on the period. Figure 2 shows the votes in the same period: after the 0-vote candle of 18 August at 20:00 it reaches 5 votes on 19 August at 12:00 (close $4,497.68), and the 5 votes stay until 25 August (4,670.42).
Read the chart in words
H4 gold chart from 15 to 25 August 2026 and, below, the number of bullish votes out of five (RSI, stochastic, CCI, MACD, EMA 50). Labels mark the candles where it reaches 5 votes.
| When | What | Price |
|---|---|---|
| 15 Aug 2026 16:00 UTC | 5 votes | 4,387.39 |
| 17 Aug 2026 04:00 UTC | 5 votes | 4,415.76 |
| 19 Aug 2026 12:00 UTC | 5 votes | 4,501.85 |
| 25 Aug 2026 16:00 UTC | 5 votes | 4,694.53 |
Times in UTC.
A voting system
You buy when the bullish votes reach a high threshold, you sell (short) when they fall to a low threshold, and you stay in the position in the intermediate states. A cost of 0.30 dollars per ounce.
| Thresholds | Trades | Winning | Mean per trade | Total | Random flips with total at least equal |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Long with ≥ 3 votes, short with ≤ 2 | 141 | 33 (23%) | +4.74 ± 8.10 dollars | +669 | 29% |
| Long with ≥ 4 votes, short with ≤ 1 | 71 | 23 (32%) | +16.92 ± 15.77 dollars | +1,201 | 13% |
| Long with 5 votes, short with 0 | 45 | 17 (38%) | +3.95 ± 22.68 dollars | +178 | 42% |
The 4/1 threshold is the best: +1,201 dollars per ounce, and chance does at least as well in 13% of trials. But it is the best of three thresholds tried (chapter 11), the mean per trade sits inside its error (16.92 against 15.77) and the winners are 32%: the profile of a trend-following system, like the average crossover (chapter 2). The votes are not extra information: they are the same trend signal counted five times.
A four-step routine
- Before combining two indicators, measure their correlation: above 0.8 they are the same signal.
- Combine indicators from different families (trend, volatility, price structure), not five oscillators.
- If you count votes, try all the thresholds and write them down: you need them to read the best one.
- Compare the system with random flips of the same number.
Exercises
Chapter exercises
1. On the chart the letters sit on four candles, with the bullish votes below. Which letter is the candle with zero bullish votes (all indicators bearish)?
Read the chart in words
| When | What | Price |
|---|---|---|
| 19 Aug 2026 12:00 UTC | Point A | 4,501.85 |
| 18 Aug 2026 20:00 UTC | Point B | 4,351.63 |
| 21 Aug 2026 04:00 UTC | Point C | 4,571.50 |
| 25 Aug 2026 16:00 UTC | Point D | 4,694.53 |
Times in UTC.
2. RSI, stochastic, CCI and bands have a mean correlation of 0.81. What does it mean for the "confirmation" between two of them?
3. The 4/1 voting system gave +1,201 dollars per ounce, the 3/2 +669 and the 5/0 +178. What do you conclude?
4. A single component explains 84% of the variance of the eight indicators. What does it say?
Have a question or want to share your exercise?
Post in the community, or join the free signals room on Telegram.
Educational content, not financial advice. Trading involves risk.