Part 4: Trading and the system · Chapter 12 of 14 · 11 min

Where to put the stop

A level that holds is still pushed through: in 50% of holds the price goes beyond by at least a quarter of an ATR before turning, in 11% by at least 1 ATR (median 0.26 ATR). A stop half an ATR beyond the zone is hit in 76% of contacts, one at 1 ATR in 67%. The return after the stop, the "stop hunt", happens in 45% of cases (at 0.5 ATR), like random levels (47%). Size changes with the stop: to risk 100 $, 5.5 ounces with 0.25 ATR and 3.4 with 1 ATR.

The stop problem

Whoever trades a level puts the stop "just beyond": below the support, above the resistance. The question is how far beyond. Too close and it is hit by a normal oscillation; too far and the risk per trade grows. And there is a widespread fear: big players know where the stops sit above and below levels and push the price there to collect them (the "stop hunt").

Here too it can be measured. For each contact with a level (chapter 1 rules) we looked at how far the price pushes beyond the level, on the side opposite to the one it arrives from, and how often a stop at a given distance is hit.

How far it pushes beyond

Maximum push beyond the level's price, in ATR (1 ATR = 18.6 $ as a median): for contacts that hold, until the moment the price moves away by 1 ATR; for those that break, in the 24 candles from the contact. Time-based levels (1,715 contacts):

ContactsMedian75th percentile90th percentile
All1.02 ATR1.55 ATR2.12 ATR
When the level holds (831)0.26 ATR0.62 ATR1.03 ATR
When the level breaks (867)1.51 ATR

A level that holds is pushed through by a quarter of an ATR as a median (about 5 $), one that breaks by an ATR and a half. For H4 swings and round numbers the values are the same: medians of 0.31 and 0.25 ATR for holds, 1.46 and 1.54 for breaks.

Among holds, the share in which the price goes beyond the level by at least a given distance before turning:

Push beyond the level of at leastTime-based levelsH4 swingsRound numbers
0.25 ATR (about 5 $)50%53%50%
0.5 ATR (about 9 $)31%35%37%
1 ATR (about 19 $)11%10%10%
1.5 ATR (about 28 $)3%4%2%

One hold in two goes beyond the level by at least a quarter of an ATR: a level that "holds" rarely does so without being touched and passed.

How often the stop is hit

If the stop sits at a given distance beyond the zone (±0.25 ATR around the level), how often is it hit in the 24 candles after the contact, regardless of the outcome of the trade?

Stop beyond the zoneTime-based levelsH4 swingsRound numbersRandom levels
0.25 ATR81%83%82%82%
0.5 ATR76%77%78%76%
1 ATR67%67%67%65%

Even with the stop at 1 ATR from the edge of the zone, the price reaches it in two contacts out of three within 24 candles. It is a number you only find by counting: the price swings 18.6 $ in an hour, and a level at 1 ATR is an hour away.

The "stop hunt"

In the phrase "they took the stops and then the price came back" there is something measurable. For each contact in which the stop is hit, we look at whether in the following 12 candles the price comes back by half an ATR to the starting side of the level (that is, for a resistance, falls half an ATR below the level). Among contacts with the stop hit:

Stop beyond the zoneThe price comes back (time-based levels)H4 swingsRound numbersRandom levels (time)
0.25 ATR52%53%55%54%
0.5 ATR45%47%49%47%
1 ATR36%36%37%36%

After the stop has been hit, the price falls back by half an ATR in about one case in two (from 36% to 55%: the closer the stop, the more often). With random levels the share is equal. The "stop hunt" thus has the frequency of a price oscillating around any point: the level does not have an extra special collection. It is not proof that stops are not hunted (we cannot see the orders): it is that, in the data, the price's behaviour after a stop touch does not change whether the level is real or invented.

"Sweep candles", that is the contact candle with a wick beyond the zone of at least a quarter of an ATR and a close that comes back inside, are 8% of contacts on time-based levels (143 out of 1,715), 10% on H4 swings (88 out of 870), 9% on round numbers (65 out of 752). The hold after such a candle is 46% (± 8), 51% (± 10), 46% (± 12): like the others (49%, 47%, 44%).

Figure 1. A level that holds after a push beyond the zone (27 August 2026, UTC hours): yesterday's low (4,586.44 $) is touched from above at 09:00, the price falls beyond the zone as far as 19.3 $ (1.12 ATR) and then moves away upwards: hold. The stops at 0.25, 0.5 and 1 ATR beyond the zone are three lines.Data: gold, XAUUSDT perpetual future (real candles) · 1 hour (H1) · from 26 Aug 2026 23:00 UTC to 28 Aug 2026 08:00 UTC.
Read the chart in words

H1 gold chart of 27 August 2026 with the zone of yesterday's low, three stop lines at 0.25, 0.5 and 1 ATR beyond the zone and the deepest push.

WhenWhatPrice
26 Aug 2026 23:00 UTCyesterday's low 4586.444,582.29 – 4,590.59
27 Aug 2026 09:00 UTCstop 0.25 ATR4,577.97
27 Aug 2026 09:00 UTCstop 0.5 ATR4,573.65
27 Aug 2026 09:00 UTCstop 1 ATR4,565.00
27 Aug 2026 13:00 UTCdeepest push 1.12 ATR4,567.14

Times in UTC.

Figure 2. A shorter push (8 January 2026, UTC hours): yesterday's low (4,424.42 $) is touched at 05:00, the price goes beyond it by 14.4 $ (1.00 ATR) at 12:00 and then holds.Data: gold, XAUUSDT perpetual future (real candles) · 1 hour (H1) · from 7 Jan 2026 19:00 UTC to 9 Jan 2026 04:00 UTC.
Read the chart in words

H1 gold chart of 8 January 2026 with the zone of yesterday's low, three stop lines at 0.25, 0.5 and 1 ATR beyond the zone and the deepest push.

WhenWhatPrice
7 Jan 2026 19:00 UTCyesterday's low 4424.424,420.80 – 4,428.04
8 Jan 2026 05:00 UTCstop 0.25 ATR4,417.18
8 Jan 2026 05:00 UTCstop 0.5 ATR4,413.56
8 Jan 2026 05:00 UTCstop 1 ATR4,406.32
8 Jan 2026 12:00 UTCdeepest push 1.00 ATR4,410.01

Times in UTC.

Size and stop

The stop decides the size: to risk a fixed amount, the further the stop the fewer ounces you buy. With a 10,000 $ account risking 1% (100 $), on the bounce at time-based levels:

Stop beyond the zoneTradesMedian riskOunces to risk 100 $Mean R
0.25 ATR57118.3 $ (25th-75th: 12.9-26.1)5.5−0.04
0.5 ATR55321.7 $ (15.6-30.0)4.6−0.04
1 ATR45529.1 $ (21.7-39.6)3.4−0.06

Widening the stop reduces the number of trades (from 571 to 455: some contacts discarded because the risk exceeds 3 ATR) and the size (from 5.5 to 3.4 ounces), but it does not improve R: −0.04, −0.04, −0.06. The choice of stop does not change the expected value, it changes how many stop-outs you take and how big the position is. It is a risk-management choice, not an edge.

Figure 3. Exercise: four H1 candles (1-2 July 2026, UTC hours) around a contact with the previous week's close (4,091.89 $), marked with the letters A-D.Data: gold, XAUUSDT perpetual future (real candles) · 1 hour (H1) · from 1 Jul 2026 03:00 UTC to 2 Jul 2026 12:00 UTC.
Read the chart in words

H1 gold chart of 1-2 July 2026 with the zone of the previous week's close and four candles marked with the letters A, B, C and D.

WhenWhatPrice
1 Jul 2026 03:00 UTClevel 4091.894,087.86 – 4,095.92
1 Jul 2026 10:00 UTCPoint A4,000.80
1 Jul 2026 13:00 UTCPoint B4,109.75
1 Jul 2026 14:00 UTCPoint C4,116.82
1 Jul 2026 23:00 UTCPoint D4,047.80

Times in UTC.

What to do with it

  1. Measure the stop in ATR from the edge of the zone. Half an ATR (about 9 $ beyond the zone) is a starting value; at 1 ATR the stop is hit in two contacts out of three, at 0.25 ATR in more than four out of five.
  2. Accept that the stop is hit often. With a 48% hold and a stop at 0.5 ATR, 76% of contacts reach it.
  3. Choose the size from the stop. Dollar risk divided by the stop distance: with 100 $ of risk, 4.6 ounces at 0.5 ATR, 3.4 at 1 ATR.
  4. Do not count on the return after the stop as a signal. After a stop touch the price comes back in about one case in two, for real and random levels.
  5. Do not change the stop to raise R. With stops at 0.25, 0.5 and 1 ATR mean R is −0.04, −0.04, −0.06: the distance adds no edge.

Procedure in four steps

  1. Choose the stop distance in ATR beyond the zone and write it down.
  2. Compute the dollar risk (entry minus stop) and the size for the risk you can afford (1% of the account).
  3. Log how many stops are hit and how many come back: for a comparison you need the same count on random levels.
  4. Do not move the stop after seeing it touched.

Exercises

Chapter exercises

1. On the chart the grey box is the previous week's close (4,091.89 $) and the letters A-D are on four candles of 1-2 July 2026 (UTC hours). Which letter is the candle with the deepest push beyond the level, before the hold?

Chart exercise. Data: gold, XAUUSDT perpetual future (real candles) · 1 hour (H1) · from 1 Jul 2026 03:00 UTC to 2 Jul 2026 12:00 UTC.
Read the chart in words
WhenWhatPrice
1 Jul 2026 03:00 UTClevel 4091.894,087.86 – 4,095.92
1 Jul 2026 10:00 UTCPoint A4,000.80
1 Jul 2026 13:00 UTCPoint B4,109.75
1 Jul 2026 14:00 UTCPoint C4,116.82
1 Jul 2026 23:00 UTCPoint D4,047.80

Times in UTC.

2. A level that holds is pushed through by at least a quarter of an ATR in 50% of holds and by at least 1 ATR in 11%. What does it mean for the stop?

3. After a half-ATR stop is hit, the price comes back by half an ATR to the starting side in 45% of cases, and random levels give 47%. How do you read it?

4. With a 10,000 $ account and 1% risk, going from a 0.25 ATR stop (median risk 18.3 $) to a 1 ATR one (29.1 $), what changes?

Have a question or want to share your exercise?

Post in the community, or join the free signals room on Telegram.

Educational content, not financial advice. Trading involves risk.