Part 1: Measuring behaviour · Chapter 3 of 14 · 8 min

How much a winner hurts

A winning trade almost always passes through a moment when it looks like a loser. In the plan, half of the wins fall by at least 0.41 R before reaching the target, 36% by at least 0.5 R and 11% by at least 0.8 R (almost at the stop). Conversely, 37% of the losses (16 out of 43) had been at +1 R before being stopped. Wins last 13 hours on median, losses 6: the plan asks you to stay in while it hurts.

MAE and MFE

For every trade, the journal (chapter 2) can record two numbers, in R:

  • MAE (maximum adverse excursion): how far the price went against you at most, from entry to exit.
  • MFE (maximum favourable excursion): how far it went in your favour at most.

They say how the road went, not just where it ended. A win with MAE 0.8 R and one with MAE 0.1 R are both worth +2.99 R, but they are two different experiences.

How much a win suffers

In the 36 wins of the plan, the maximum adverse excursion before reaching the target:

MeasureValue
Median MAE0.41 R
75th percentile0.58 R
90th percentile0.85 R
Wins with MAE ≥ 0.5 R36%
Wins with MAE ≥ 0.8 R11%
Wins with MAE ≥ 0.95 R (almost stopped)3%

More than one win in three (36%) went through a moment when it was losing half a risk, and one in nine (11%) through one where it was a hair from the stop (0.8 R or more). Across all 96 rules with N = 80 the picture is similar: 16% of wins had an MAE of at least 0.8 R.

Figure 1. A win of the plan (18-19 March 2026, UTC hours): sell at 4,825.31 $ after the break of the 80-candle low (4,837.49 $), stop at 4,873.62 $ (48.3 $), target at 4,680.37 $ reached at 10:00 on 19 March, +2.99 R. In the meantime the price rose against the position up to 0.89 R from the stop.Data: gold, XAUUSDT perpetual future (real candles) · 1 hour (H1) · from 18 Mar 2026 08:00 UTC to 19 Mar 2026 18:00 UTC.
Read the chart in words

Hourly gold chart of 18-19 March 2026 with the entry, the near stop, the target and the 80-candle low of a winning sell.

WhenWhatPrice
18 Mar 2026 20:00 UTCentry4,825.31
18 Mar 2026 20:00 UTCstop: −1 R (48.3 $)4,873.62
18 Mar 2026 20:00 UTCtarget: +3 R4,680.37
18 Mar 2026 12:00 UTC80-candle low4,837.49

Times in UTC.

In this win (14 hours in the trade) the price rose against the position up to 0.89 R, that is about 5 $ from the stop, and then fell all the way to the target. Whoever had tightened the stop "for safety" during that phase would have been stopped out.

How much gain a loss saw

Conversely, the 43 losses of the plan, with the maximum favourable excursion before being stopped:

MeasureValue
Median MFE0.61 R
75th percentile1.24 R
Losses that had been at +0.5 R or more53% (23 out of 43)
Losses that had been at +1 R or more37% (16 out of 43)
Losses that had been at +2 R or more7% (3 out of 43)

Almost two losses out of five (16 out of 43) had had, at some point, an unrealised gain of at least 1 R. Those 16 losses are worth −15.2 R in all. Overall, 66% of all trades reach at least +1 R, 49% at least +2 R, and only 41% reach the 3 R target.

Figure 2. A loss of the plan (23-24 February 2026, UTC hours): buy at 5,193.99 $ after the break of the 80-candle high (5,178.76 $), stop at 5,160.96 $ (33.0 $), target at 5,293.09 $. The price rose to +1.80 R and then fell, stopping at −1.01 R at one in the morning.Data: gold, XAUUSDT perpetual future (real candles) · 1 hour (H1) · from 23 Feb 2026 02:00 UTC to 24 Feb 2026 09:00 UTC.
Read the chart in words

Hourly gold chart of 23-24 February 2026 with the entry, the stop, the far target and the 80-candle high of a losing buy.

WhenWhatPrice
23 Feb 2026 14:00 UTCentry5,193.99
23 Feb 2026 14:00 UTCstop: −1 R (33.0 $)5,160.96
23 Feb 2026 14:00 UTCtarget: +3 R5,293.09
23 Feb 2026 06:00 UTC80-candle high5,178.76

Times in UTC.

At +1.80 R there were still 1.2 R to the 3 R target: it is the situation in which the voice "close now and take the gain" is loudest. Whoever closed there would have collected +1.8 R instead of −1.01, and would have given up the 3 R in all the other trades in which the price, from there, reached it.

Duration: the part that weighs

WinsLosses
Median duration13 hours6 hours
75th percentile28 hours15 hours

Losses arrive early (median 6 hours, the time to touch the stop) and wins take longer (13 hours, and one in four more than 28). Whoever holds a loss understands quickly how it goes; whoever holds a win on its way must stay in while the price moves against them, for a whole day, without knowing whether it will be a win.

What follows

The two numbers together explain the temptations we will measure:

  • Cutting the gains (chapter 6): 66% of trades see at least +1 R, and closing there gives a gain that seems safe.
  • Tightening or moving the stop to avoid suffering: 36% of wins lose half a risk before winning (chapter 6).
  • Widening the stop (chapter 7): the moment when the price is 0.8 R against is the one in which the idea of giving it room is strongest.
  • Skipping after losses (chapter 4): a loss arrives early and hurts at once.

None of these choices is proof of weakness: they are understandable answers to real data. The point of the plan is to decide them beforehand, with the numbers.

What to do with it

  1. Record MAE and MFE of every trade, in R.
  2. Look at the distribution, not the single case: the win that suffered is normal, and so is the loss that had gained.
  3. Write beforehand what you do at +1 R and at 0.5 R against (move the stop? close? nothing?) and measure the cost of the rule (chapters 6 and 7).
  4. Remember the duration: if wins last a day, a plan that asks you not to touch anything for a day costs attention.
  5. Do not judge the trade by the moment: judge it by the plan.

Procedure in four steps

  1. For every trade, record MAE and MFE in R.
  2. Compute, for wins and losses, the distribution of MAE and MFE and the duration.
  3. Write the rules for the two hard moments (+1 R in profit, 0.8 R against) before you face them.
  4. Measure on your plan the cost of each rule (chapters 6 and 7).

Exercises

Chapter exercises

1. In the plan, what share of wins falls by at least half a risk (0.5 R) before reaching the target?

2. 37% of the losses of the plan (16 out of 43) had been at +1 R or more before being stopped. What does it say?

3. Wins last 13 hours on median and losses 6. What does it mean for whoever executes the plan?

4. A win fell to 0.89 R against before reaching the target. What would have happened with the stop tightened "for safety"?

Have a question or want to share your exercise?

Post in the community, or join the free signals room on Telegram.

Educational content, not financial advice. Trading involves risk.