FREE BOOK · PSYCHOLOGY
Psychology and the trading journal from A to Z: measuring behavioural mistakes
The Academy's thirteenth book in 14 chapters: why psychology can be measured, the trading journal, how much a winner hurts, feeling the losses, the few big winners, cutting the gains, widening the stop, size after streaks, too many signals, the weight of the outcome, patience, the cost of behaviours and how to build discipline. Each chapter explains how it works, what a typical behaviour costs simulated on real gold trades and what to do with it. With exercises, a glossary and a final test.
14 chapters · 4 modules · 2 hours of reading, approx. · updated 2026-11-20
How to use this book
Every chapter has figures on real gold candles, four exercises with the solution explained and a recap of the key points. Do the exercises before you move on to the next chapter. Educational content, not financial advice.
Part 1: Measuring behaviour
Why psychology can be measured, the trading journal and how much a winner hurts.
- 1Why psychology can be measuredWe do not measure emotions: we measure the gap between the plan and what you do, in R. Take a written plan (the 79 trades of the 80-candle breakout of book 12: 46% winning, average win 2.79 R, average loss 0.99 R, losing streak 6, +58.1 R in ten months) and simulate one behaviour at a time on the same trades. The cost of each is read in R and compared with how much luck alone moves the result (from +30 to +86 R). · 7 min
- 2The trading journalThe trading journal is the memory that does not deceive: every trade in R, with the plan and the deviations. On our plan, 79 rows already give everything you need: mean R by direction (buys +0.79 ± 0.58 over 42, sells +0.68 ± 0.64 over 37: indistinguishable), by hour band (from +0.18 to +1.66, with 6-38 trades per band) and by month (from −2.1 to +15.6 R). But every cut reduces the trades: ten bands with 16 trades are not a discovery, they are multiple trials. · 8 min
- 3How much a winner hurtsA winning trade almost always passes through a moment when it looks like a loser. In the plan, half of the wins fall by at least 0.41 R before reaching the target, 36% by at least 0.5 R and 11% by at least 0.8 R (almost at the stop). Conversely, 37% of the losses (16 out of 43) had been at +1 R before being stopped. Wins last 13 hours on median, losses 6: the plan asks you to stay in while it hurts. · 8 min
Part 2: Losses and winners
Feeling the losses, the few big winners, cutting the gains and widening the stop.
- 4Feeling the lossesAfter a streak of losses the temptation is to skip the next trades. On the plan, skipping the 2 trades after 2 losses in a row leaves the mean R almost the same (+0.67 against +0.74 R) but removes a third of the gain (+38.0 against +58.1 R), because the skipped trades were wins and losses in proportion. After a loss the winning share stays 45%, like after a win (44%): chance has no memory. The drawdown, if anything, rises (from 6.1 to 7.1-8.1 R). · 8 min
- 5The few big winnersThe plan earns with 32 trades out of 79, those that reach the 3 R target: alone they are worth about +96 R, and the other 47 take away about 38. Skipping 5 at random costs 15 R (26% of the gain), 10 cost 30 R (51%). Skipping 20% of trades at random leaves mean R the same but moves the sum from +58.1 to +46.5 R (from +34 to +58 R between 5th and 95th percentile). Skipping the "uncomfortable" trades costs more: the 19 with the widest stop are worth +16.9 R, the 22 at night +32.5 R. · 7 min
- 6Cutting the gainsClosing before the target raises the winning share and lowers the gain. On the plan, bringing the target from 3 to 1.5 R leaves wins at 49% (from 46%) but mean R falls from +0.74 to +0.23 and the sum from +58.1 to +25.8 R; at 1 R wins are 59% and the gain +20.8 R. On 120 rules with a 3 R target, moving to 1.5 R worsens mean R in 68% of cases (−0.06 on average). Moving the stop to breakeven after +1 R costs little (−0.01 on average) and reduces the plan's drawdown from 6.1 to 4.1 R. · 8 min
- 7Widening the stopWidening the stop to "give the trade room" raises the winning share (from 46% to 57-60%) and leaves mean R almost the same in original R (+0.73 at 2 times, +0.61 at 3), but the average loss goes from 0.99 to 1.71-2.32 R and the drawdown from 6.1 to 10.3-11.1 R. If to keep the dollar risk equal you halve the size, the gain per unit of risk halves (+0.37). On 120 rules the difference in mean R is zero and the drawdown grows on average by 4.6 R. · 8 min
Part 3: Size, signals and outcome
Size after streaks, too many signals, the weight of the outcome and patience.
- 8Size after streaksChanging the size according to how the last trade went is the most expensive deviation. On the plan (with an edge in the data) doubling after a loss takes capital from 176% to 336% but the drawdown from 5.9% to 17.8% (65.5% with a 5% base risk). On a rule with no edge the same doubling gives a median capital of 60% against 86%, and in 42% of cases the account ends below 50%. Halving the size after every loss reduces the drawdown (3.5%) and the growth (150%). · 8 min
- 9Too many signalsAdding signals raises the number of trades and lowers the quality of each. On the plan (80-candle breakout, 79 trades, +0.74 ± 0.43 R) whoever adds the same rule at 10 candles makes 289 with +0.36 R on average and +104.5 R in sum: the sum rises, but mean R halves and the added rule (+0.22 ± 0.24) cannot be told apart from zero. Entries without a signal, at random and with a narrow stop, make −0.10 R per trade: 961 trades and about −94 R. · 8 min
- 10The weight of the outcomeExecuting the plan perfectly does not avoid losses: 54% of trades lose, 36% of the weeks with closed trades are negative (14 out of 39), and 36% of the windows of 4 consecutive trades. The result of a trade, of a week, even of a month (3 out of 10 are negative) says little about the quality of the decision. About 2,950 trades are needed to see an edge of 0.1 R with this dispersion: to judge behaviour you look at adherence, not at the result. · 8 min
- 11PatienceExecuting a plan is mostly waiting. Our plan opens a position every 3 days on median, with pauses up to 12.4 days; it has a position open for 23% of the hours and does nothing for 77%; it stays below the account's high for 62% of the time, with a stretch of 57 days without a new high; and wins last 13 hours on median (one in four beyond 28). Patience has four times, and each has its typical deviation. · 7 min
Part 4: The cost and discipline
The cost of behaviours, building discipline, mistakes, glossary and final test.
- 12The cost of behavioursWe put the behaviours of the previous chapters on the same 79 trades: the «prudent» one (break-even stop after +1 R, 2 R target) loses 19.1 R, the «impatient» one (1.5 R target) 32.3 R, the «fearful» one (skips 2 after 2 losses) 20.1 R, the «hopeful» one (widened stop) 5.8 R, and the drawdown rises from 6.1 to 10.3 R. All three flaws together keep 42% of the gain (+24.4 against +58.1 R) and lift the winning share to 65%: the behaviour that feels best is the one that costs most. · 8 min
- 13Building disciplineDiscipline does not show in the result: a deviation costing 0.1 R per trade is worth about 0.8 R a month against a monthly spread of about 6 R, and about 2,950 trades are needed to see it. You build it on four numbers you can count right away (adherence, deviations by type, cost in R, review), on «if... then» rules written beforehand and on a weekly check. The example plan, with three flaws together, finishes below the band of luck alone (+24.4 R against the +30.4 R threshold): the band says when a difference is too big to be chance. · 10 min
- 14A journal told twice, mistakes, reference, glossary and final testThe same trader told in two ways: «65% wins, black streaks of 4 at most, a 9 R drawdown, +24 R» and «low adherence, three deviations that cost 33.7 R on a plan of +58.1 R, outside the band of luck alone». Then the most frequent mistakes in chapter order, the quick reference with rules and measurements, the glossary and a final test of 15 questions. · 18 min