Part 4: The cost and discipline · Chapter 14 of 14 · 18 min
A journal told twice, mistakes, reference, glossary and final test
The same trader told in two ways: «65% wins, black streaks of 4 at most, a 9 R drawdown, +24 R» and «low adherence, three deviations that cost 33.7 R on a plan of +58.1 R, outside the band of luck alone». Then the most frequent mistakes in chapter order, the quick reference with rules and measurements, the glossary and a final test of 15 questions.
A journal told twice
Take the «all together» profile of chapter 12: an imaginary trader who, on the same plan, skips two trades after two losses, cuts the target to 1.5 R and widens the stop to two times. No such trader exists, and that is the point: it puts together the three deviations the book measured one by one.
The story that comforts. «Ten months, 80 trades, 65% wins, black streaks of 4 at most, maximum drawdown 9.1 R, +24.4 R. The market was hard, but I held on.» All true, and the journal looks beautiful.
The story that informs. The same trades, with all the numbers of the book:
| Question | Answer (chapter) |
|---|---|
| What was the plan? | 79 trades in 9.7 months, 46% winning, +0.74 ± 0.43 R, +58.1 R, drawdown 6.1 R: an example plan with an unproven edge (1) |
| Which deviations? | Three: signals skipped after losses, 1.5 R target, stop at two times (4, 6, 7) |
| How much do they cost? | −33.7 R in all: 42% of the plan's gain is left (12) |
| Why does it seem to go better? | More wins (65% against 46%) and shorter black streaks (4 against 6): the deviations improve the feelings and worsen the account (6, 7, 12) |
| What risk was taken? | The stop at two times is a double risk: at equal risk the gain per unit of risk is +0.37 R, not +0.74 (7) |
| Does it show in the results? | Yes, here: +24.4 R is below the 5th percentile of luck (+30.4 R). The prudent (−19.1 R) and the fearful (−20.1 R) sit inside the band and do not show (12) |
| Was it a bad year? | 14 weeks out of 39 and 3 months out of 10 are negative even with the plan executed to perfection (10) |
| How could you have known earlier? | By counting adherence and deviations trade by trade, not by looking at the account (10, 13) |
The difference between the two stories is not in the data: it is in the question. The first asks «how did I feel», the second «what did each deviation cost and what does chance say». The journal of chapter 2 exists so that you can answer the second.
The most common mistakes
| Mistake | Chapter |
|---|---|
| Explaining a bad result with «I was nervous» without checking whether the plan was executed; looking for a «psychological flaw» without measuring what it costs | 1 |
| Recording only the important trades or correcting the journal after the result; slicing the data on a few trades and seeing a discovery | 2 |
| Believing that «a right trade does not fall»; remembering the loss that had been in profit as «the gain I left» | 3 |
| Skipping after two losses because «the next one will be another loss»; coming back to trade after a win «because the market is good again» | 4 |
| Thinking that «one trade fewer changes nothing»; skipping the ones that «do not convince» without noting them | 5 |
| Closing «by eye» at +1.5 R because «it will come back»; judging the plan by the winning share | 6 |
| Moving the stop «just this once» and seeing it work; reading in original R a result obtained with halved size | 7 |
| Raising the size after a loss to «recover»; judging the rule from a single series without the 95th percentile of the drawdown | 8 |
| Judging the addition of a rule by the sum; entering «because price is moving» and not recording it as a deviation | 9 |
| Judging a week by its result; changing the plan after a window of 4-10 trades | 10 |
| Reading 12 days without signals as «the plan does not work»; expecting a rising curve every day | 11 |
| Praising yourself for the wins and the streaks without looking at the gain; putting down to luck a 20 R difference that sits inside the band of chance | 12 |
| Measuring discipline from the account; writing twenty rules and rereading none | 13 |
Quick reference: the rules
| Concept | Rule of the book | Ch. |
|---|---|---|
| Method | Same trades, one deviation at a time, difference in R, comparison with luck | 1 |
| Journal | Every trade, skipped signals included; never corrected after the result; adherence field | 2 |
| The trade's path | MAE and MFE in R; even wins fall before they rise | 3 |
| After losses | There is no memory to exploit; a pause only if written beforehand, with its cost | 4 |
| Selection | The big wins are few: skipping by hand is an expensive choice | 5 |
| Exits | Target and break-even stop written beforehand; no closing by eye | 6 |
| Stop | Moved only to protect, and only if written; original R and risk per unit | 7 |
| Size | Fixed in the plan, changed only at the review | 8 |
| Signals | Sum versus mean R and error; entry without a signal = deviation | 9 |
| Judgement | Behaviour by adherence, the plan by the result over a window decided beforehand | 10 |
| Waiting | Four waits, one line of the plan for each | 11 |
| Cost | Rank deviations by cost in R, not by frequency | 12 |
| Discipline | Four numbers, «if... then» rules, checklist, weekly review | 13 |
Quick reference: the measurements
| Ch. | Result |
|---|---|
| 1 | Plan: 79 trades in 9.7 months, 46% winning, average win 2.79 R, average loss 0.99 R, losing streak 6, +58.1 R, drawdown 6.1 R; luck alone moves the sum from +30.4 to +85.7 R |
| 2 | Buys +0.79 ± 0.58 R, sells +0.68 ± 0.64 R; ten hourly slots with 6-38 trades |
| 3 | Half the wins fall by at least 0.41 R before arriving, 36% by 0.5 R, 11% by 0.8 R; 16 losses out of 43 had been at +1 R (−15.2 R); wins 13 hours, losses 6 hours |
| 4 | Winning share after a loss 45%, after a win 44%; skipping 2 after 2 losses: +38.0 R against +58.1 R |
| 5 | 32 trades at target (+100.6 R) carry the plan; skipping 5 costs 15 R, 10 cost 29.9 R; skipping 20% at random: +46.5 R (34-58) |
| 6 | Target 3 / 2 / 1.5 / 1 R: +0.74 / +0.32 / +0.23 / +0.17 R per trade; break-even stop after +1 R: +52.9 R, drawdown 4.1 R, 26 break-evens |
| 7 | Stop at 2 times: wins 57%, average loss 1.71 R, drawdown 10.3 R, +0.73 R (+0.37 per unit of risk) |
| 8 | Doubling after a loss: 336% against 176% with drawdown 17.8% against 5.9%; no edge: median capital 60% against 86%, below 50% in 42% of cases against 6% |
| 9 | 10-candle rule added: 289 trades, +104.5 R but +0.36 R per trade; random entries with a tight stop: 961 trades, −0.10 R |
| 10 | Executed plan: 54% of trades losing, 14 weeks out of 39 and 3 months out of 10 negative; 2,950 trades to see 0.1 R, 118 for 0.5 R |
| 11 | Median pause 3.0 days, maximum 12.4; position open for 23% of the hours; below the account's high for 62% of the time (longest period 57 days) |
| 12 | Prudent −19.1 R, impatient −32.3 R, fearful −20.1 R, hopeful −5.8 R, all together −33.7 R (42% of the gain) |
| 13 | A 0.1 R deviation ≈ 0.8 R a month against about 6 R of spread; adherence error ±6.6 / ±8.8 points (79 trades), ±10.7 / ±14.3 (30); 1.5 R target = −4.1 R a month |
All the measurements come from an example plan of 79 trades over ten months of a single instrument (December 2025 - October 2026, gold perpetual future on Binance, prices only), with an unproven edge (book 12). The behaviours are simulated on the same trades: the book measures what they cost, not how many traders have them.
Glossary
The terms of the book are in the site glossary, where each one has an example with numbers.
| Term | Definition |
|---|---|
| Trading journal | The written memory of every trade: plan, entry, stop, target, result in R, reason for exit, adherence to the plan and a note written before entering. |
| Plan adherence | The share of trades executed exactly as the plan foresees (signal, entry, stop, target, size) out of all those the plan foresaw, skipped signals included. |
| Plan deviation | A trade or a decision that does not match the written plan: a skipped signal, an early exit, a moved stop, a changed size, an entry without a signal. |
| Maximum adverse excursion (MAE) | The maximum distance, in R, by which price moved against the position between entry and exit. |
| Maximum favourable excursion (MFE) | The maximum distance, in R, by which price moved in favour of the position between entry and exit. |
| Skipped signal | A signal foreseen by the plan that is not acted on: out of fear, because of a pause after losses, because it "does not convince". |
| Cutting gains | Closing a win before the plan's target, or lowering the target, to protect a small profit. |
| Widening the stop | Moving the stop further from the price after entry, or choosing it wider than the plan, to "give the trade room". |
| Size after streaks | Changing the position size according to the outcome of the last trades: doubling after a loss "to recover" or raising after some wins "because I am in form". |
| Overtrading | Trading more than the plan foresees, by adding signals or entering without a written signal because "price is moving". |
| Outcome bias | The error of judging the quality of a decision by its outcome: a win seems "well taken", a loss "badly taken". |
| Judgement window | The number of trades or the period, decided beforehand, over which the result of a plan is evaluated, and within which it is not changed. |
| Cost of a behaviour | The difference in R between the result of the executed plan and that of the same series of trades with a deviation, one at a time. |
| "If... then" rule | A line of the plan written beforehand, in the form "if X happens, then I do Y", for the situations where you have already deviated. |
What to do now
- Write the plan, with signal, stop, target, size, exceptions and what you do in the four waits (chapter 11).
- Keep the journal with the adherence field and the skipped signals (chapter 2), without ever correcting it.
- Count four numbers: adherence, deviations by type, cost in R, reviews done (chapter 13).
- Write three or four «if... then» rules for the most expensive deviations and use the checklist before every entry.
- Do the weekly review at a fixed time: adherence first, result after.
- Judge the plan over the window decided beforehand, with small risk (book 11) and a forward test (book 12), not over a week.
- For the foundations: the «Market structure» book, the «Order blocks from A to Z» book, the «FVG and liquidity» book, the «SMC: the whole system» book, the «Indicators from A to Z» book, the «Elliott and Fibonacci» book, the «Chart patterns» book, the «Japanese candlesticks» book, the «Hours, sessions and news» book, the «Support, resistance and levels» book, the «Risk and position sizing» book and the «Backtesting and overfitting» book. For risk and discipline: the risk and psychology course.
Final test
Fifteen questions on the book. You pass the test with at least 12 right answers.
Final test of the book
1. In the chart the lines are entry (4,548.32 $), stop (4,575.18 $) and target (4,467.74 $) of a sell on 29 April 2026 (UTC time); the line on the left is the 80-candle low (4,556.63 $). Which letter is the candle in which the stop is hit?
Read the chart in words
| When | What | Price |
|---|---|---|
| 29 Apr 2026 12:00 UTC | entry | 4,548.32 |
| 29 Apr 2026 12:00 UTC | stop: −1 R (26.9 $) | 4,575.18 |
| 29 Apr 2026 12:00 UTC | target: +3 R | 4,467.74 |
| 29 Apr 2026 04:00 UTC | 80-candle low | 4,556.63 |
| 29 Apr 2026 08:00 UTC | Point A | 4,580.69 |
| 29 Apr 2026 12:00 UTC | Point B | 4,572.40 |
| 29 Apr 2026 23:00 UTC | Point C | 4,564.20 |
| 30 Apr 2026 00:00 UTC | Point D | 4,577.00 |
Times in UTC.
2. In the chart the lines are entry (4,409.35 $), stop (4,436.48 $) and target (4,327.96 $) of a sell on 5 June 2026 (UTC time), with the 80-candle low at 4,425.55 $. Which letter is the signal and entry candle?
Read the chart in words
| When | What | Price |
|---|---|---|
| 5 Jun 2026 12:00 UTC | entry | 4,409.35 |
| 5 Jun 2026 12:00 UTC | stop: −1 R (27.1 $) | 4,436.48 |
| 5 Jun 2026 12:00 UTC | target: +3 R | 4,327.96 |
| 5 Jun 2026 04:00 UTC | 80-candle low | 4,425.55 |
| 5 Jun 2026 08:00 UTC | Point A | 4,470.09 |
| 5 Jun 2026 12:00 UTC | Point B | 4,478.35 |
| 5 Jun 2026 15:00 UTC | Point C | 4,375.86 |
| 5 Jun 2026 16:00 UTC | Point D | 4,349.10 |
Times in UTC.
3. What is the book's method for finding out what a behaviour costs?
4. Which field of the trading journal matters most for judging behaviour?
5. In the plan 36% of the wins fall, before arriving, by at least how much?
6. After a loss the share of winning trades is 45%, after a win 44%. What does it imply for whoever skips the signal after two losses?
7. The plan earns with 32 trades out of 79. What does it cost to skip 5 of those that hit the target?
8. With the target lowered from 3 R to 1.5 R, what happens to the wins and to the gain?
9. With the stop at two times the average loss goes from 0.99 to 1.71 R and the drawdown from 6.1 to 10.3 R. What do you read in the almost unchanged mean R?
10. On a rule with no edge, what does doubling the size after a loss do?
11. You add a rule to the plan and the sum goes from +58.1 to +104.5 R, but the mean R from +0.74 to +0.36. What do you look at to judge?
12. A perfectly executed plan closes a week at −2 R. What do you do?
13. For what share of the time is the account of the plan (which earns) below its high?
14. The «all together» profile has 65% wins and +24.4 R against the plan's +58.1 R. How do you read it?
15. Which of these is NOT one of the four numbers used to measure discipline?
Have a question or want to share your exercise?
Post in the community, or join the free signals room on Telegram.
Educational content, not financial advice. Trading involves risk.