Part 4: The cost and discipline · Chapter 12 of 14 · 8 min

The cost of behaviours

We put the behaviours of the previous chapters on the same 79 trades: the «prudent» one (break-even stop after +1 R, 2 R target) loses 19.1 R, the «impatient» one (1.5 R target) 32.3 R, the «fearful» one (skips 2 after 2 losses) 20.1 R, the «hopeful» one (widened stop) 5.8 R, and the drawdown rises from 6.1 to 10.3 R. All three flaws together keep 42% of the gain (+24.4 against +58.1 R) and lift the winning share to 65%: the behaviour that feels best is the one that costs most.

The profiles

We take the behaviours measured in the previous chapters and group them into profiles, each applied to the same 79 trades of the plan. They are not portraits of people: they are ways of deviating, described in a recognisable way.

ProfileWhat it doesTradesMean R ± errorSumDrawdownLosing streakWinning
Plannothing79+0.74 ± 0.43+58.1 R6.1 R646%
Prudentbreak-even stop after +1 R, 2 R target100+0.39 ± 0.26+39.0 R5.1 R739%
Impatient1.5 R target114+0.23 ± 0.23+25.8 R6.6 R649%
Hopefulstop widened to 2 times72+0.73 ± 0.53+52.3 R10.3 R657%
Fearfulskips 2 trades after 2 losses57+0.67 ± 0.50+38.0 R7.1 R744%
All togetherfearful, impatient and hopeful80+0.30 ± 0.36+24.4 R9.1 R465%

And the cost against the plan:

ProfileDifference in mean RDifference in sumShare of the plan's sum
Prudent−0.35−19.1 R67%
Impatient−0.51−32.3 R44%
Hopeful−0.01−5.8 R90%
Fearful−0.07−20.1 R65%
All together−0.43−33.7 R42%
Figure 1. Cumulative R: plan (pink, +58.1 R), prudent (blue, +39.0), impatient (grey bars, +25.8), fearful (dashed blue, +38.0) and all together (dashed grey, +24.4). The plan finishes above all the others.Data: gold, XAUUSDT perpetual future (real candles) · daily (D1) · from 15 Dec 2025 to 5 Oct 2026.
Read the chart in words

Daily gold chart with, below, five cumulative R curves: the plan on top, the other four lower and close to each other.

Three observations.

  1. Each behaviour costs between 10% and 56% of the gain (from 5.8 to 32.3 R). The most expensive is the cut target (−32.3 R), because it removes the big wins the plan lives on. The widened stop looks almost free (−0.01 R per trade), but that result is in original R, that is with a double risk per trade: at equal risk the gain per unit of risk halves (chapter 7), and the drawdown rises from 6.1 to 10.3 R.
  2. The most gratifying behaviour is also among the most expensive. «All together» has 65% wins (instead of 46%) and the longest losing streak is 4 (instead of 6): the journal looks beautiful. It has 42% of the plan's gain, +24.4 R instead of +58.1. Whoever looks at the winning share and the streaks sees an improvement; whoever looks at the sum sees a loss of 33.7 R.
  3. The costs do not add up. «All together» costs 33.7 R, almost as much as the «impatient» alone (32.3 R) and less than the three costs taken one by one (5.8 + 20.1 + 32.3 = 58.2 R). With a low target the big wins are already gone, and the widened stop and the skips have less to take away. It is no consolation: almost all the damage already comes from the cut target.

What shows in the results

Here is the point of the chapter. The plan's sum over 79 trades, if the results are drawn at random, goes from +30.4 R (5th percentile) to +85.7 R (95th percentile), with a median of +57.7: a spread of 55 R due to luck alone.

  • The impatient (+25.8 R) and «all together» (+24.4 R) sit below the 5th percentile: the cost (−32.3 and −33.7 R) is larger than the spread and shows in the results. Whoever has a plan expected around +58 R and makes +25 has something to notice.
  • The prudent (+39.0 R) and the fearful (+38.0 R) sit inside the band of chance (30-86): ordinary luck explains their result. They cost 19-20 R and do not show in ten months of results.
  • The hopeful (+52.3 R) sits well inside the band: its cost in sum (5.8 R) is invisible, and the one in drawdown (+4.2 R) would show only in an unlucky period. The real cost lies in the double risk taken to get it.

The most harmful cost is the one that does not show: a prudent or fearful trader loses a third of the gain without the result saying so, and can put the difference down to luck or to the market.

What follows

The cost of a behaviour is calculated with a measurement, while the behaviour is judged by adherence and not by the result (chapter 10). Four steps:

  1. List your typical deviations from the journal (chapter 2), and count how many trades they touch.
  2. Calculate the cost of each with the method of this book: same trades, one deviation at a time.
  3. Rank by cost, not by frequency or by annoyance: the cut target, here, costs more than any other.
  4. Work on the most expensive first, with a written rule and a weekly check.

What to do

  1. Measure your deviations, one at a time, on your own trades.
  2. Do not judge by winning share or losing streaks: a journal that looks better can cost more than one that looks worse.
  3. Distrust invisible costs: a cost inside the spread of chance does not show, and it lasts.
  4. Start from the most expensive deviation, not the most frequent one.
  5. Retake the numbers every quarter: the spread of chance shrinks with the number of trades, and the costs become visible.

Procedure in four steps

  1. List the deviations from the journal with their frequency.
  2. Calculate the cost in R of each on the same trades.
  3. Compare each cost with the spread of chance (5th-95th percentile of the sum).
  4. Work on the deviation that costs most, with a written rule.

Exercises

Chapter exercises

1. The «all together» profile has 65% wins (the plan 46%) and +24.4 R against +58.1 R. How do you read it?

2. The plan's sum over 79 trades, by luck alone, goes from +30.4 to +85.7 R. Which of these behaviours would not show in the results?

3. The impatient (1.5 R target) makes +25.8 R, below the 5th percentile of luck (+30.4 R). What does it mean?

4. Which deviation should you start from to work on discipline?

Have a question or want to share your exercise?

Post in the community, or join the free signals room on Telegram.

Educational content, not financial advice. Trading involves risk.