Part 3: Size, signals and outcome · Chapter 10 of 14 · 8 min

The weight of the outcome

Executing the plan perfectly does not avoid losses: 54% of trades lose, 36% of the weeks with closed trades are negative (14 out of 39), and 36% of the windows of 4 consecutive trades. The result of a trade, of a week, even of a month (3 out of 10 are negative) says little about the quality of the decision. About 2,950 trades are needed to see an edge of 0.1 R with this dispersion: to judge behaviour you look at adherence, not at the result.

Outcome bias

Outcome bias is judging the quality of a decision by its outcome. A winning trade seems "well taken", a losing one "badly taken". The reasoning is understandable and wrong: in a plan that loses 54% of the time, a perfect decision (executing the plan) has more chances of losing than of winning. The result of a single trade is dominated by chance.

Two consequences, both harmful:

  • After a loss from an executed plan, you think "I got it wrong" and change something (chapters 4, 6, 7, 8).
  • After a win from a deviation ("I closed early and did well"; "I widened the stop and it worked"), you reinforce a behaviour that costs (chapters 6 and 7: the 57% of wins with the widened stop).

How often a well-executed plan loses

Numbers on the plan (79 trades, +0.74 ± 0.43 R, all executed as per plan):

UnitHow manyNegativeMinimum sumMaximum sum
Single trade7954%−1.02 R+2.99 R
4 consecutive trades76 windows36%−4.1 R+10.2 R
10 consecutive trades70 windows7%−2.1 R+17.9 R
20 consecutive trades60 windows0%+4.7 R+26.5 R
Week (with closed trades)3936% (14)−2.0 R+9.0 R
Month1030% (3)−2.1 R+15.6 R

One week in three (14 out of 39) of a perfectly executed plan closes at a loss, and one window of four trades in three. In the 39 weeks with closed trades the average weekly sum is +1.49 R with a deviation of 2.91 R: the sign of a week says almost nothing. At four weeks (about a month) things improve, but three months out of ten are still near zero or negative (−0.1, −0.4, −2.1 R). Only from 20 trades on, in this series, is the sum always positive; but it is a single series with an unproven edge.

Figure 1. R of each week of the plan, marked at the end of the week: 14 weeks out of 39 with closed trades are losing (minimum −2.0 R), the others go up to +9.0 R. The average weekly sum is +1.49 R with a deviation of 2.91 R.Data: gold, XAUUSDT perpetual future (real candles) · daily (D1) · from 15 Dec 2025 to 5 Oct 2026.
Read the chart in words

Daily gold chart with, below, bars of the weekly R of the plan: one week in three below zero, some very high.

The window of judgment

This has a practical consequence: the window in which you judge. After a week, four trades, a month, you do not have the information to say whether the plan works or whether it was executed well. To see an edge of 0.1 R per trade with a deviation of 1.94 R you need about 2,950 trades (power 80%, book 11, chapter 12); to see one of 0.5 R you need 118. And a behaviour that costs 0.1 R per trade (for example a target cut a little more often) is in the same order of magnitude: it does not show in the results for years.

So behaviour is not judged by the result. It is judged by something you can count at any moment: adherence. For each trade, was the plan executed (yes/no)? If yes, the decision was right, whatever the outcome; if no, there is a deviation, whose cost you know from the measurements of this book. The journal (chapter 2) makes this distinction by itself: one field for the outcome, one for adherence.

The four-box matrix:

Good outcomeBad outcome
Plan executedMerit of the plan (and a bit of luck)Normal: it happens 54% of the time
Plan not executedLuck: reinforces a behaviour that costsThe cost of the deviation, plus chance

The two boxes that count are the bottom left and the top right: a normal loss must not be punished, a win from a deviation must not be rewarded.

After three losses in a row

In the plan, after three losses in a row, the winning share of the following trades is 6 out of 11 (55%), against 46% in general. With 11 cases you can only say "there is no signal". It is the kind of moment in which the weight of the outcome is felt; and it is the moment in which the number to look at is adherence, not the last loss.

What to do with it

  1. Record the adherence of every trade, before the outcome if possible.
  2. Evaluate the week by adherence, not by result: "did I execute all the planned trades?".
  3. Fix a window of judgment for the result (for example 100 trades or 6 months) and respect it.
  4. Do not reward a win from a deviation, and note it as a deviation even if it went well.
  5. Do not punish a loss from an executed plan: it is one of those (54 trades out of 100) that are part of the plan.

Procedure in four steps

  1. For each trade mark adherence (yes/no) and, if no, the deviation.
  2. Every week look at adherence (how many trades executed out of how many planned) before the result.
  3. Judge the result only on the window decided in advance.
  4. Do not change the plan in the middle of a window.

Exercises

Chapter exercises

1. A perfectly executed plan has 14 weeks out of 39 at a loss (36%). What does it mean for whoever judges from one week?

2. In 4 consecutive trades the sum is negative in 36% of cases, in 20 in 0%. What does it imply?

3. You closed early a trade outside the plan and it won. What do you do?

4. Why is behaviour judged by adherence and not by the result?

Have a question or want to share your exercise?

Post in the community, or join the free signals room on Telegram.

Educational content, not financial advice. Trading involves risk.