Part 1: Measuring behaviour · Chapter 1 of 14 · 7 min

Why psychology can be measured

We do not measure emotions: we measure the gap between the plan and what you do, in R. Take a written plan (the 79 trades of the 80-candle breakout of book 12: 46% winning, average win 2.79 R, average loss 0.99 R, losing streak 6, +58.1 R in ten months) and simulate one behaviour at a time on the same trades. The cost of each is read in R and compared with how much luck alone moves the result (from +30 to +86 R).

What is measured

Of a trader we do not measure emotions. We measure what they do: whether they skip a trade, whether they close before the target, whether they move the stop, whether they change the size. Every time what they do differs from the written plan there is a gap, and the gap has a cost in R that can be computed.

This book measures the cost of behaviours. It does not measure how many traders have them: we have no data on real people, and we do not say that "the average trader" does this or that. We say: if a trader did this, on the plan that follows, they would lose so much. It is information that does not depend on opinions, and that can be used to decide what to write in your journal and which rules to set.

The reference plan

To measure behaviours you need a plan with real trades. We use the best rule of book 12, 80-candle breakout, 1.5 ATR stop, 3 R target, maximum duration 48 candles (gold, hourly candles, 15 December 2025 - 6 October 2026, cost 0.3 $). Note: its edge is not proven (book 12, chapter 13). We use it as an example plan because it has a typical structure (few big wins and many small losses) and because the measurements hold for any plan: what is computed is the difference from the plan, whatever the plan is.

Measure of the planValue
Trades79 in 9.7 months: 8.1 a month, one every 3.7 days
Mean R ± error+0.74 ± 0.43
Winning36 out of 79 (46%)
Average win / average loss2.79 R / 0.99 R
Exits32 at the target, 42 at the stop, 5 at time
Median durationwins 13 hours, losses 6 hours (maximum 48)
Longest losing streak6
Maximum drawdown6.1 R
Sum+58.1 R
Figure 1. Cumulative R of the reference plan (80-candle breakout, 1.5 ATR stop, 3 R target): 79 trades, +58.1 R, December 2025 - October 2026.Data: gold, XAUUSDT perpetual future (real candles) · daily (D1) · from 15 Dec 2025 to 5 Oct 2026.
Read the chart in words

Daily gold chart with, below, the cumulative R curve of the plan, rising in steps.

The plan has a very recognisable character: it loses more than half the time (54%) and earns with a few big wins. It is a profile that makes it hard to stick to the plan, and for that reason it is a good test bench.

The method of the book

In every chapter we do the same thing:

  1. Take the same set of trades as the plan (the same 79, with the same prices).
  2. Simulate one behaviour at a time: skipping after losses, cutting the target, widening the stop, changing the size.
  3. Measure the difference in mean R, in sum, in drawdown and in losing streaks.
  4. Compare with luck: the sum of the plan over 79 trades, shuffling the results at random, goes from +30 R (5th percentile) to +86 R (95th). A behaviour that costs 5 R sits inside this noise and does not show in the results; one that costs 30 R does.

Where possible we also check on all 480 rules of book 12, to see whether the effect depends on the plan chosen or is general.

What is in the book

The behaviours measured are those that appear most often in traders' accounts (and that you can recognise in your own journal): skipping trades after losses (chapter 4), missing the few big winners (5), cutting the gains (6), widening the stop (7), changing size after streaks (8), adding signals (9), judging by the outcome (10) and not waiting (11). Chapter 12 puts them together, 13 explains how to build discipline with the journal and 14 summarises. First, chapter 2 builds the tool that everything needs: the trading journal in R.

What to do with it

  1. Write the plan so that it can be applied without judgment (book 12, chapter 1).
  2. Call "deviation" every gap between plan and execution, even a small one, and count it.
  3. Compute the cost in R of each type of deviation before judging it.
  4. Compare the cost with the dispersion of luck: it grows with the number of trades.
  5. Do not ask what you feel: ask what you did and what it costs.

Procedure in four steps

  1. Write the plan with numbers (entry, stop, target, time exit, size).
  2. Record every trade and every gap from the plan.
  3. For each type of gap compute the cost in R on the same trades.
  4. Compare the cost with the dispersion of the result due to luck alone.

Exercises

Chapter exercises

1. On the chart the lines are the entry (4,583.03 $), the stop (4,608.96 $) and the target (4,505.23 $) of a short trade of 27 August 2026 (UTC hours); the line on the left is the 80-candle low (4,586.44 $), which the price broke downwards. Which letter is the candle in which the stop is hit?

Chart exercise. Data: gold, XAUUSDT perpetual future (real candles) · 1 hour (H1) · from 26 Aug 2026 19:00 UTC to 28 Aug 2026 01:00 UTC.
Read the chart in words
WhenWhatPrice
27 Aug 2026 09:00 UTCentry4,583.03
27 Aug 2026 09:00 UTCstop: −1 R (25.9 $)4,608.96
27 Aug 2026 09:00 UTCtarget: +3 R4,505.23
27 Aug 2026 01:00 UTC80-candle low4,586.44
27 Aug 2026 05:00 UTCPoint A4,624.55
27 Aug 2026 09:00 UTCPoint B4,604.10
27 Aug 2026 14:00 UTCPoint C4,601.19
27 Aug 2026 15:00 UTCPoint D4,613.69

Times in UTC.

2. What does this book measure of a trader's psychology?

3. The plan has 79 trades and the sum, shuffling the results at random, goes from +30 to +86 R. What does it imply for a behaviour that costs 5 R?

4. The plan loses 54% of the time but earns 2.79 R when it wins. Why is it a good test bench?

Have a question or want to share your exercise?

Post in the community, or join the free signals room on Telegram.

Educational content, not financial advice. Trading involves risk.