Part 3: What happens to levels · Chapter 8 of 14 · 10 min

The retest after the break

After a true break the price comes back to touch the old level from the new side in 75% of cases within three days (median: 10 candles). The "support that becomes resistance" holds 50% (± 4), like random levels (50%). A resistance broken upwards: the retest holds 56% (± 6); a support broken downwards: 45% (± 6): differences inside the error.

Polarity

There is an idea in technical-analysis courses that links supports and resistances: polarity. When the price breaks a resistance, that resistance becomes a support: if the price comes back to touch it from above, it should bounce. And the same the other way round: a broken support becomes a resistance. The return is called a retest.

The explanation is that whoever sold below the resistance and found themselves at a loss buys to exit at breakeven, whoever bought the break defends the position: there are orders on the new side. It is a sensible explanation and it can be counted.

In the book: a true break (chapter 7: one close beyond the zone, then a close at 1 ATR beyond the zone) opens a window of 72 market-open H1 candles (three trading days). The retest is the first contact with the zone from the new side. The outcome is measured as in chapter 1: hold if the price moves away by 1 ATR in the direction of the break (the old obstacle holds), break if it goes back beyond by 1 ATR. The comparison is with random levels shifted by 2-6 ATR, treated with the same procedure.

How often there is a retest

On time-based levels (previous day, week, Asia) there are 820 true breaks with one close. In 613 (75%) the price comes back to touch the zone from the new side within three days. With random levels the share is the same (74%). The retest is fast: a median of 10 candles from the end of the break, 56% within 12 candles and 79% within 24.

The retest arrives often: it is the behaviour of a price that oscillates, not of a special level. The old level is close to the price, which finds it again without difficulty.

Does the retest hold?

LevelsTrue breaksTrue breaks, retestRetest holdRandom levels (retest, hold)
Time-based levels, break with one close820613 (75%)50% (± 4)74%, 50%
Time-based levels, break at 0.5 ATR beyond the zone1,227918 (75%)50% (± 3)74%, 49%
H4 swings, break with one close405302 (75%)49% (± 6)76%, 50%
H4 swings, break at 0.5 ATR beyond the zone623455 (73%)47% (± 5)76%, 49%
50 $ round numbers, break with one close337260 (77%)48% (± 6)74%, 51%
50 $ round numbers, break at 0.5 ATR beyond the zone543403 (74%)45% (± 5)74%, 49%

Six rows, six results close to 50% (45-50%) and all equal to random levels. Polarity does not show: the retest of a broken level holds like contact with any other price.

The round numbers at 0.5 ATR (45%) are the only row a little lower, and consistent with what we saw in chapter 5: round numbers hold a little less, on either side.

Resistance becoming support, and vice versa

Polarity has two directions. On time-based levels:

DirectionRetestsHoldRandom levels
Resistance broken upwards: retest from above, expected "support"30856% (± 6)51%
Support broken downwards: retest from below, expected "resistance"30545% (± 6)48%

The difference between the two directions is 11 points. At first sight it seems that "support" holds better than "resistance". With random levels the difference is 3 points (51% against 48%), and the error on the comparison is about 8 points: the larger part is explained by chance, not by the level. A hold of 56% over 308 cases is inside 50% ± 6.

When the retest arrives

A retest within 12 candles (346 cases) holds 53% (± 5), between 12 and 36 candles (198) 48% (± 7), between 36 and 72 (69) 43% (± 12). The more time passes, the less it holds: a pattern entirely inside the error and still to retest. The common thread: no band stands clearly away from 50%.

The retest is not a light touch: within the 12 candles from the contact, the price goes beyond the level (in the case of a resistance broken upwards, below it) by more than a quarter of an ATR in 82% of retests, by 1.4 ATR as a median. Whoever puts the stop just beyond the zone is stopped almost always (chapter 12).

Figure 1. A retest that holds (21-23 April 2026, UTC hours): the H4 swing low (4,731.76 $) is broken upwards, the price carries on and comes back to touch the zone from above on 22 April at 14:00: the old obstacle holds and the price rises again.Data: gold, XAUUSDT perpetual future (real candles) · 1 hour (H1) · from 21 Apr 2026 15:00 UTC to 23 Apr 2026 05:00 UTC.
Read the chart in words

H1 gold chart of 21-23 April 2026 with a level's zone, the break and the retest marked.

WhenWhatPrice
21 Apr 2026 15:00 UTClevel 4731.764,724.85 – 4,738.67
21 Apr 2026 23:00 UTCbreak4,739.91
22 Apr 2026 14:00 UTCretest: hold4,732.42

Times in UTC.

Figure 2. A retest that gives way (28 May - 1 June 2026, UTC hours): the level (4,492.09 $) is broken upwards, the price comes back to touch the zone from above on 1 June at 07:00 and passes it again: the retest does not hold.Data: gold, XAUUSDT perpetual future (real candles) · 1 hour (H1) · from 28 May 2026 08:00 UTC to 1 Jun 2026 18:00 UTC.
Read the chart in words

H1 gold chart from 28 May to 1 June 2026 with a level's zone, the break and the retest marked.

WhenWhatPrice
28 May 2026 08:00 UTClevel 4492.094,486.31 – 4,497.87
28 May 2026 16:00 UTCbreak4,512.40
1 Jun 2026 07:00 UTCretest: break4,495.51

Times in UTC.

Figure 3. Exercise: four H1 candles (14-15 July 2026, UTC hours) around an upward break of a level (4,024.54 $) and its retest, marked with the letters A-D.Data: gold, XAUUSDT perpetual future (real candles) · 1 hour (H1) · from 14 Jul 2026 03:00 UTC to 15 Jul 2026 18:00 UTC.
Read the chart in words

H1 gold chart of 14-15 July 2026 with a level's zone and four candles marked with the letters A, B, C and D.

WhenWhatPrice
14 Jul 2026 03:00 UTClevel 4024.544,021.70 – 4,027.38
14 Jul 2026 07:00 UTCPoint A4,032.03
14 Jul 2026 11:00 UTCPoint B4,033.96
15 Jul 2026 05:00 UTCPoint C4,039.37
15 Jul 2026 15:00 UTCPoint D4,064.90

Times in UTC.

What to do with it

  1. Expect the retest, not the bounce. After a true break, the price comes back to the level in 75% of cases within three days, with a median of 10 candles. It is a chance for a limit order, not a signal of direction.
  2. Do not count on polarity. The old support holds like an ordinary price (50%).
  3. Put the stop beyond the typical depth of the retest. As a median the price passes the level by 1.4 ATR in the 12 candles after the contact; a stop a quarter of an ATR from the level is hit in 82% of cases.
  4. Do not tell the stories of retests that held. With a 50% hold, half the retests hold and make a nice chart; the other half do not.
  5. Compare with random levels for retests too. The 75% of retests and the 50% hold are found with levels shifted at random.

Procedure in five steps

  1. Define the true break (one close beyond the zone and then 1 ATR beyond).
  2. Open a window of 72 candles and mark the first contact from the new side.
  3. Measure the retest hold (1 ATR in the direction of the break against 1 ATR back).
  4. Redo it on random levels and compare.
  5. Measure the depth of the retest to choose the stop distance.

Exercises

Chapter exercises

1. On the chart the grey box is the zone of a level (4,024.54 $) broken upwards on 14 July, and the letters A-D are on four H1 candles. Which letter is the retest candle, the first contact with the zone from the new side (from above)?

Chart exercise. Data: gold, XAUUSDT perpetual future (real candles) · 1 hour (H1) · from 14 Jul 2026 03:00 UTC to 15 Jul 2026 18:00 UTC.
Read the chart in words
WhenWhatPrice
14 Jul 2026 03:00 UTClevel 4024.544,021.70 – 4,027.38
14 Jul 2026 07:00 UTCPoint A4,032.03
14 Jul 2026 11:00 UTCPoint B4,033.96
15 Jul 2026 05:00 UTCPoint C4,039.37
15 Jul 2026 15:00 UTCPoint D4,064.90

Times in UTC.

2. After a true break the price comes back to touch the zone in 75% of cases within three days; random levels give 74%. What does it mean?

3. The retest of a broken level holds 50% (± 4) on time-based levels, and random levels give 50%. How do you read it?

4. In the 12 candles from the retest, the price passes beyond the level by more than a quarter of an ATR in 82% of cases. What does it imply for the stop?

Have a question or want to share your exercise?

Post in the community, or join the free signals room on Telegram.

Educational content, not financial advice. Trading involves risk.