Part 3: What happens to levels · Chapter 7 of 14 · 9 min

True and false breaks

With one close beyond the zone the price comes back (a false break) in 42% of cases on time-based levels; asking for two closes it falls to 31%, at 0.5 ATR to 26%, at 1 ATR to 12%. The same numbers come out with random levels: the frequency of false breaks depends on how much you ask for to say there is a break, not on the level.

What a break is

In chapter 1 the break was the outcome of a contact at 1 ATR. Here we look at it up close, because it is the moment that matters to whoever trades: the price passes the level. Whoever buys the break expects the price to carry on; whoever sells the "false break" bets that it comes back.

The book's definition: a break is the first H1 close beyond the level's zone (beyond ±0.25 ATR), on the side opposite to the one the price came from. From the break close, for 24 candles:

  • True break: the price closes at least 1 ATR beyond the zone, before coming back.
  • False break: the price closes back on the starting side, beyond the zone.

It is the same scheme as hold and break in chapter 1 but with the thresholds moved: the continuation requires 1 ATR beyond the zone (about 18.6 $ plus 4.7 $), the return requires going back across the zone.

How many are false

On time-based levels (previous day, week, Asia) there are 1,432 breaks with one close beyond the zone. 42% are false (they come back), 57% true. On H4 swings 40% (694 breaks), on 50 $ round numbers 44% (610). Random levels shifted by 2-6 ATR give 42%, 42% and 43%.

Among the false ones the return is quick: a median of three H1 candles, 61% within 3 candles and 82% within 6. For the true ones, the 1 ATR continuation arrives in a median of two candles.

By time band the false ones go from 38% (evening and Asia, 619 breaks) to 48% (American afternoon, 177); by direction, 45% of upward breaks and 39% of downward ones. Differences inside the error (± 4-7 points).

The definition decides

This is the most important part of the chapter. We change how much we ask for to say a break has happened: two consecutive closes beyond the zone, a close at 0.5 ATR beyond the zone, a close at 1 ATR beyond the zone. And we count again.

Definition of breakTime-based levelsH4 swings50 $ round numbersRandom levels
One close beyond the zone42% (1,432)40% (694)44% (610)42-43%
Two closes beyond the zone31% (1,274)32% (611)34% (538)31-32%
One close at 0.5 ATR beyond the zone26% (1,658)24% (831)27% (748)25-26%
One close at 1 ATR beyond the zone12% (1,816)11% (978)12% (871)11-12%

Percentage of false breaks (and, in brackets, the number of breaks). Read the table by row: the more you ask for to say the price has broken, the fewer false breaks there are, from 42% to 12%. And read it by column: real levels and random ones give the same value at every definition. There is no level that "has more false breaks than the others".

The frequency of false breaks is not a property of the level. It depends on how much is needed to declare the break: if 5 $ beyond the level is enough the price often comes back, if you ask for 23 (1 ATR plus the zone) it rarely does, because you have already seen the price move 23 $ the right way.

What confirmation costs

"Wait for confirmation" is the most widespread advice on breaks. It works, in the sense that false breaks decrease (from 42% to 12%). The price to pay can be read on the chart: with our ATR (18.6 $), a close at 0.5 ATR beyond the zone means entering 9.3 $ further on than the level, at 1 ATR 18.6 $ further on. Whoever waits to see the price go ahead buys dearer, and that gain already made belonged to someone else. If random levels give the same curve, confirmation is not a property of the level: it is the price of a move that has already happened.

Chapter 11 puts all this into trades, with cost and a random comparison.

Figure 1. A true break (24-26 February 2026, UTC hours): the H4 swing high (5,178.76 $) is exceeded at 05:00 on 25 February with a close beyond the zone; the price carries on by more than 1 ATR (23.5 $) at 16:00 without coming back.Data: gold, XAUUSDT perpetual future (real candles) · 1 hour (H1) · from 24 Feb 2026 17:00 UTC to 26 Feb 2026 04:00 UTC.
Read the chart in words

H1 gold chart of 24-26 February 2026 with a level's zone, the break close and the continuation and return lines.

WhenWhatPrice
24 Feb 2026 17:00 UTClevel 5178.765,172.62 – 5,184.90
25 Feb 2026 05:00 UTCbreak: close beyond the zone5,203.20
25 Feb 2026 05:00 UTCcontinuation: 1 ATR beyond the zone5,208.38
25 Feb 2026 05:00 UTCreturn to the starting side5,172.62
25 Feb 2026 16:00 UTCtrue5,213.39

Times in UTC.

Figure 2. A false break (8-9 January 2026, UTC hours): the H4 swing high (4,468.73 $) is exceeded with a close at 20:00 and four hours later the price closes back below the zone.Data: gold, XAUUSDT perpetual future (real candles) · 1 hour (H1) · from 8 Jan 2026 08:00 UTC to 9 Jan 2026 19:00 UTC.
Read the chart in words

H1 gold chart of 8-9 January 2026 with a level's zone, the break close and the continuation and return lines.

WhenWhatPrice
8 Jan 2026 08:00 UTClevel 4468.734,465.02 – 4,472.44
8 Jan 2026 20:00 UTCbreak: close beyond the zone4,476.26
8 Jan 2026 20:00 UTCcontinuation: 1 ATR beyond the zone4,487.63
8 Jan 2026 20:00 UTCreturn to the starting side4,465.02
9 Jan 2026 00:00 UTCfalse4,462.00

Times in UTC.

Why there are always "false breaks"

A price that passes a level and then comes back is a normal thing for a random walk: in a walk that swings ±18 $ in an hour, passing a point by 5 $ and coming back is frequent. In the books the "false break" has a name and a theory (the stop run). In our data we have as many as a random level would give, so it is not proof that stop run exists: it is what a moving price does.

Figure 3. Exercise: four H1 candles (10-11 May 2026, UTC hours) around the downward break of an H4 swing high (4,694.23 $), marked with the letters A-D.Data: gold, XAUUSDT perpetual future (real candles) · 1 hour (H1) · from 10 May 2026 12:00 UTC to 11 May 2026 23:00 UTC.
Read the chart in words

H1 gold chart of 10-11 May 2026 with a level's zone and four candles marked with the letters A, B, C and D.

WhenWhatPrice
10 May 2026 12:00 UTClevel 4694.234,689.78 – 4,698.68
10 May 2026 19:00 UTCPoint A4,733.25
11 May 2026 00:00 UTCPoint B4,697.00
11 May 2026 05:00 UTCPoint C4,682.50
11 May 2026 11:00 UTCPoint D4,679.58

Times in UTC.

What to do with it

  1. Write the definition of break before looking at the results. One close, two, a margin in ATR: the percentage of false ones depends on that, not on the level.
  2. Do not say "this level has many false breaks". To know you need a comparison with random levels at the same definition: in our data there is none.
  3. Put a price on confirmation. Half an ATR means entering 9.3 $ further on, one ATR 18.6 $; decide whether you accept it.
  4. Do not count on false breaks as a signal. The 42% (or the 12%, depending on the definition) is the behaviour of an ordinary price.
  5. Use the return as an exit rule, not as a prediction. If the price closes back inside the zone, the break has failed: it is a point for the stop (chapter 12).

Procedure in four steps

  1. Write the definition: how many closes, beyond what margin.
  2. Count the breaks and the false ones (return to the starting side) with the same definition.
  3. Redo the count on levels shifted at random.
  4. Compare; if they are equal, the level has no behaviour of its own.

Exercises

Chapter exercises

1. On the chart the grey box is the zone of an H4 swing high (4,694.23 $), and the letters A-D are on four candles of 10-11 May 2026 (UTC hours). Which letter is the break candle, the first that closes beyond the zone on the side opposite to the starting one?

Chart exercise. Data: gold, XAUUSDT perpetual future (real candles) · 1 hour (H1) · from 10 May 2026 12:00 UTC to 11 May 2026 23:00 UTC.
Read the chart in words
WhenWhatPrice
10 May 2026 12:00 UTClevel 4694.234,689.78 – 4,698.68
10 May 2026 19:00 UTCPoint A4,733.25
11 May 2026 00:00 UTCPoint B4,697.00
11 May 2026 05:00 UTCPoint C4,682.50
11 May 2026 11:00 UTCPoint D4,679.58

Times in UTC.

2. With one close beyond the zone false breaks are 42%, with one close at 1 ATR beyond the zone 12%. What does it mean?

3. Real levels and random levels both have 42% false breaks with one close beyond the zone. What do you take from it?

4. "Wait for confirmation" (a close at 0.5 ATR beyond the zone) reduces false breaks from 42% to 26%. What is the price?

Have a question or want to share your exercise?

Post in the community, or join the free signals room on Telegram.

Educational content, not financial advice. Trading involves risk.