Part 3: Size, signals and outcome · Chapter 8 of 14 · 8 min

Size after streaks

Changing the size according to how the last trade went is the most expensive deviation. On the plan (with an edge in the data) doubling after a loss takes capital from 176% to 336% but the drawdown from 5.9% to 17.8% (65.5% with a 5% base risk). On a rule with no edge the same doubling gives a median capital of 60% against 86%, and in 42% of cases the account ends below 50%. Halving the size after every loss reduces the drawdown (3.5%) and the growth (150%).

Three ways of changing size

After a loss, or after a win, the size of the next trade seems something to decide on the spot. Three common behaviours:

  • Revenge: after a loss you double, to recover (martingale: book 11, chapter 5).
  • Confidence: after two wins you increase, because "I am in form".
  • Prudence: after a loss you halve, so as not to get worse.

As with all deviations, the cost is measured on the same trades. The plan, base risk 1% on current capital, in the order in which the trades happened (79):

Size ruleFinal capitalDrawdown
Fixed size (plan)176%5.9%
Doubling after a loss (maximum 4 times)336%17.8%
Doubling after 2 wins in a row (then back to 1)188%6.9%
Half size after a loss150%3.5%
1.5 after a win, 0.5 after a loss166%4.6%
Figure 1. Capital in % of the initial one (base risk 1%): fixed size (pink, 176%), doubling after a loss (blue, 336%) and half size after a loss (bars, 150%). Doubling rises more and falls more.Data: gold, XAUUSDT perpetual future (real candles) · daily (D1) · from 15 Dec 2025 to 5 Oct 2026.
Read the chart in words

Daily gold chart with, below, three capital curves: the one with doubling much higher and more irregular, the half-size one lower and smoother.

Doubling after a loss gave almost double the capital (336% against 176%), with a drawdown three times larger (17.8% against 5.9%). It seems a good idea. It is not, and the reason is in the next two sets of numbers.

When doubling works

The plan has an edge in the data (+0.74 R, not proven) and the longest losing streak is 6 (with doubling limited to 4 times, the maximum risk is 4%). In this series losses were followed by a win fairly soon, and doubling amplified the gain. Shuffling the order of the 79 trades 5,000 times:

Size ruleMedian capital (5th percentile)Median drawdown (95th percentile)
Fixed size176% (133%)6.0% (10.8%)
Doubling after a loss320% (177%)17.8% (33.1%)
Doubling after 2 wins193% (134%)6.9% (11.6%)
Half size after a loss151% (121%)4.0% (6.9%)
1.5 after a win, 0.5 after a loss169% (124%)5.5% (9.2%)

With an edge and a losing streak that does not get long, doubling returns more and risks more: the 95th percentile of the drawdown is 33.1% against 10.8%. With a 5% base risk doubling gives 8,471% and a drawdown of 65.5% (fixed size: 1,237% and 26.8%): the same pattern, with enormous numbers and a step from ruin.

When it does not work

If there is no edge, doubling does not create one. Take the no-edge rule of book 12 (20-candle breakout, 1 ATR stop, 1 R target: 307 trades, −0.02 ± 0.11 R), with a base risk of 2%:

Size ruleFinal capital (real order)Drawdown
Fixed size86%24.6%
Doubling after a loss53%57.1%
Doubling after 2 wins68%44.6%
Half size after a loss95%18.2%
1.5 after a win, 0.5 after a loss96%25.3%

And shuffling the order of the 307 trades 4,000 times:

Size ruleMedian capital (5th percentile)Median drawdown (95th percentile)Final under 50%
Fixed size86% (48%)36.5% (58.5%)6%
Doubling after a loss60% (13%)68.9% (91.5%)42%

On a rule with no edge doubling takes the median capital from 86% to 60% and makes the account end below 50% in 42% of cases (against 6%). The median drawdown is almost 69%.

The difference between the two cases is what the trader does not know: whether their plan has an edge (and how much), and how long the next streak of losses will be (book 11, chapter 3: from 4 to 8 in a long run). Doubling earns if you are right about the first and loses everything if you are wrong about the second.

Prudence and confidence

Half size after a loss reduces the drawdown (3.5% instead of 5.9%) and reduces growth (150% instead of 176%): it is like having a smaller risk, with its advantages and its costs. On the no-edge rule it loses less (95% against 86%). It is not irrational if it is a rule of the plan; it is if it is decided after the loss, with fear, differently each time.

Confidence after two wins gave results close to the plan (188% against 176%, drawdown 6.9% against 5.9%) on this series, and on the one with no edge it lost (68% against 86%, drawdown 44.6%): it rewards the plan when wins really come in streaks, and punishes it when there is no memory (chapter 4: after a win the winning share is 44%, not more).

What to do with it

  1. Fix the size in the plan (book 11, chapter 5: fixed fraction, 0.5-2%) and do not change it according to the last result.
  2. If you want to reduce size after losses, use a written drawdown rule (book 11, chapter 13: half risk at −10%).
  3. Never double after a loss: it requires an edge and a short streak, and you know neither.
  4. Record the actual size of every trade and compare it with the plan's: the deviation is the datum.
  5. Change the size only at the review, in writing.

Procedure in four steps

  1. Write in the plan the size rule (fixed, or with drawdown steps) and the base risk.
  2. Record the actual size of every trade.
  3. Mark as a deviation every size different from the plan's and its result.
  4. Every month compare the real capital with what you would have had at fixed size.

Exercises

Chapter exercises

1. On the plan, doubling after a loss gives 336% capital against 176%, but with a drawdown of 17.8% against 5.9%. How is it read?

2. On a rule with no edge, doubling after a loss (2% risk) makes the account end below 50% in what share of cases?

3. Half size after a loss takes capital from 176% to 150% and the drawdown from 5.9% to 3.5%. What is it, in substance?

4. After two wins in a row the winning share of the next one is 44%. What does it imply for the rule "doubling after two wins"?

Have a question or want to share your exercise?

Post in the community, or join the free signals room on Telegram.

Educational content, not financial advice. Trading involves risk.