Part 2: Losses and winners · Chapter 7 of 14 · 8 min
Widening the stop
Widening the stop to "give the trade room" raises the winning share (from 46% to 57-60%) and leaves mean R almost the same in original R (+0.73 at 2 times, +0.61 at 3), but the average loss goes from 0.99 to 1.71-2.32 R and the drawdown from 6.1 to 10.3-11.1 R. If to keep the dollar risk equal you halve the size, the gain per unit of risk halves (+0.37). On 120 rules the difference in mean R is zero and the drawdown grows on average by 4.6 R.
The temptation
The price is 0.8 R against, a step from the stop. In chapter 3 we saw that 36% of wins pass through at least 0.5 R against and 11% through 0.8 R or more. The voice says: "give it room, it will come back". The stop is moved away, and most often it is done at the moment the price is about to touch it. It is a deviation from the plan: the loss is no longer −1 R but more, and how much more is decided on the spot.
To measure it without being fooled, we simulate a systematically wider stop: at 1.5, 2 and 3 times that of the plan, with the same target (3 R of the original risk) and R always computed on the original risk. If the size stays that of the plan, every loss weighs more.
What the data say
| Stop | Trades | Mean R ± error | Sum | Drawdown | Winning | Average loss | Worst loss |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Plan (1×) | 79 | +0.74 ± 0.43 | +58.1 R | 6.1 R | 46% | 0.99 R | −1.02 R |
| 1.5× | 76 | +0.65 ± 0.48 | +49.1 R | 6.3 R | 50% | 1.40 R | −1.52 R |
| 2× | 72 | +0.73 ± 0.53 | +52.3 R | 10.3 R | 57% | 1.71 R | −2.02 R |
| 3× | 70 | +0.61 ± 0.61 | +42.6 R | 11.1 R | 60% | 2.32 R | −3.02 R |
Read the chart in words
Daily gold chart with, below, three cumulative R curves: the plan highest, the one with the stop at 2 times close, the one at 3 times lower.
Three things, in order.
- It seems to work. Wins rise from 46% to 57% (at 2 times) and to 60% (at 3): some trades that would have touched the stop come back and reach the target (from 36 to 41 wins over a smaller number of trades). The longest losing streak falls from 6 to 5 (at 1.5 times) and to 3 (at 3 times). Whoever looks at the journal sees more wins and fewer black streaks.
- Mean R stays almost the same in the original numbers (from +0.61 to +0.73 against +0.74), with an error of ±0.5-0.6. But it obtains it with much larger losses: the average loss goes from 0.99 to 1.71 R (2×) and to 2.32 R (3×), the worst from −1.02 to −3.02 R.
- The drawdown grows: from 6.1 to 10.3 R (2×) and to 11.1 R (3×), almost double. With 1% risk per R that is −10-11% of the account against −6%.
On all the 120 rules of the grid with a 3 R target, the stop at 2 times gives an average difference in mean R of 0.00 (it worsens in 50% of cases) and a drawdown higher by 4.6 R on average. The effect is general: higher winning share, same gain, larger drawdown.
The bill you do not see
With the stop at 2 times and the same size, the true risk per trade is double that of the plan: if the plan risks 1% of the account, you risk 2%. The mean R of +0.73 is expressed in original R, that is in units of the plan's risk. If to return to risking 1% you halve the size, every result halves: the gain per unit of risk is +0.37 R instead of +0.74. Half of the edge disappears.
In other words, widening the stop at an unchanged size increases the risk and leaves the gain the same; at constant risk, it halves it. In neither case does it improve.
Why it seems right
Because memory is poor. The price that comes back after brushing the stop is the story you tell yourself ("I was almost out"); the price that continues and makes you lose double is another trade, of which less is said. In chapter 3 we saw that 11% of wins reach 0.8 R against: they are the ones that "would have proved you right". There are also the others, and by widening the stop the losses of those are worth 1.7-2.3 R instead of 1.
In book 10 we measured that, after touching a stop, the price comes back more or less as it does after a stop placed on a random level: the return is a normal behaviour of the price, not proof that the stop was wrong.
What to do with it
- Put the stop where the idea is wrong, once (book 11, chapter 8), and do not move it against you.
- If you think the stop is too narrow, change the plan, with numbers (looking at the parameter map of book 12), not the trade.
- Record every stop moved and the loss that followed.
- Compute the true risk, in original R, of every trade with a moved stop.
- Remember that more wins does not mean more gain: look at mean R and drawdown.
Procedure in four steps
- Write in the plan that the stop is not moved against the position.
- If you want a wider stop, change the plan in writing and redo all the measures (mean R, drawdown, risk).
- Record every move as a deviation, with the final loss in original R.
- Compare the average loss with that of the plan (0.99 R) and the drawdown with its own.
Exercises
Chapter exercises
1. With the stop at 2 times the winning share rises from 46% to 57%. What happens to the average loss?
2. With the stop at 2 times and the same size, how much do you risk per trade compared with the plan?
3. You halve the size to return to the same dollar risk. Mean R in original R is +0.73. What is it per unit of risk?
4. The drawdown with the stop at 2 times is 10.3 R against 6.1 R. With 1% risk per R, what does it mean?
Have a question or want to share your exercise?
Post in the community, or join the free signals room on Telegram.
Educational content, not financial advice. Trading involves risk.