Part 2: Losses and winners · Chapter 5 of 14 · 7 min
The few big winners
The plan earns with 32 trades out of 79, those that reach the 3 R target: alone they are worth about +96 R, and the other 47 take away about 38. Skipping 5 at random costs 15 R (26% of the gain), 10 cost 30 R (51%). Skipping 20% of trades at random leaves mean R the same but moves the sum from +58.1 to +46.5 R (from +34 to +58 R between 5th and 95th percentile). Skipping the "uncomfortable" trades costs more: the 19 with the widest stop are worth +16.9 R, the 22 at night +32.5 R.
The gain sits in a few trades
In the plan, 32 trades out of 79 (40%) reach the target and each is worth about +2.99 R. The others are 42 trades stopped out (about −1 R each) and 5 time exits, 4 of them in profit. The account by outcome:
| Group | Trades | R |
|---|---|---|
| Wins (all) | 36 | +100.6 |
| Losses (all) | 43 | −42.5 |
| Total | 79 | +58.1 |
The gain is the difference between two large numbers, and depends on all 32 trades that reach the target being there. What is it worth to lose some?
| If I skip | Sum of the plan | Share of the gain lost |
|---|---|---|
| None | +58.1 R | 0% |
| 5 trades at the target (15.0 R) | +43.1 R | 26% |
| 10 (29.9 R) | +28.1 R | 52% |
| 15 | +13.2 R | 77% |
(They are all almost identical trades, at +2.99 R: "the best" are the 32 that reach the target.) Five lost trades take away a quarter of the gain; fifteen bring it to a sixth.
The months show it in the same way: two months out of ten (January, +15.6 R, and August, +14.1 R) are worth +29.7 R, more than half the total.
Read the chart in words
Daily gold chart with, below, three cumulative R curves: the plan highest, the one without 5 trades in the middle, the one without 10 lowest.
Skipping at random
The simplest case: now and then a signal is not taken, from distraction, a meeting, a doubt. We simulate skipping at random a share of the trades, 5,000 times:
| Share skipped | Median sum (5th-95th percentile) | Median mean R | Sum under 30 R | Sum under zero |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10% | +52.8 R (from 42.8 to 60.8) | +0.74 | 0% | 0% |
| 20% | +46.5 R (from 34.2 to 58.2) | +0.73 | 1% | 0% |
| 40% | +34.8 R (from 19.9 to 49.5) | +0.73 | 30% | 0% |
Skipping at random does not change mean R per trade: it removes in proportion. It changes the sum, which falls in proportion to how much you skip (−10%, −20%, −40%) and disperses more. The real risk is skipping by chance one of the trades that matter: with 10% skips, the probability of losing at least one of the 5 worth 15 R is 41%; with 20% it is 67%; with 40% it is 92%.
Skipping the uncomfortable trades
The more insidious case is not random: you skip what frightens. For example, trades with the widest stop (which show more dollars of risk), or those that fall at night (when you cannot watch the screen). In the plan:
| Group of trades | Trades | Mean R ± error | Sum | Winning |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Widest stop (above the 75th percentile, over 35.5 $) | 19 | +0.89 ± 0.92 | +16.9 R | 47% |
| All the others | 60 | +0.69 ± 0.48 | +41.2 R | 45% |
| Night entries (21-07 UTC) | 22 | +1.48 ± 0.81 | +32.5 R | 64% |
| Day entries (07-21 UTC) | 57 | +0.45 ± 0.49 | +25.6 R | 39% |
A trader who "does not take" the 19 trades with the widest stop loses 16.9 R (29% of the gain); one who does not trade at night loses 32.5 R (56%). They are cuts of the journal with few trades and a large error (±0.8-0.9): they do not say that the night "is better", a small slice of a ten-month sample says it (chapter 2). They say something simpler and more important: the trades the plan asks you to take are not distributed at the comfortable moments, and a plan executed halfway is no longer that plan.
What to do with it
- First of all, make the plan executable: if it requires trading at night and you cannot, it is not the plan for you (change it in writing, not by habit).
- Count the skipped signals (chapter 2) and their hypothetical cost.
- Automate what you can: orders already set with stop and target, alerts on signals.
- Treat the size of the stop as data: a wide stop is not a worse trade (here +0.89 R) but requires fewer ounces.
- Do not decide which trades to take on the spot: decide it in the plan.
Procedure in four steps
- Count in the plan how many trades produce the gain (here 32 out of 79).
- Compute what it costs to skip 5 and 10.
- For every skipped signal, note why and the hypothetical result.
- Every month look at which types of trade you skip (wide stop, night, after a loss) and their cost.
Exercises
Chapter exercises
1. Skipping 5 trades at the target (about 15 R) on a plan of +58.1 R, what share of the gain does it remove?
2. Skipping 20% of the trades at random, what changes most?
3. A trader does not trade at night because they cannot watch the screen. In the plan the 22 night trades are worth +32.5 R out of +58.1. What must be concluded?
4. With 10% random skips, what is the probability of losing at least one of the 5 trades worth 15 R?
Have a question or want to share your exercise?
Post in the community, or join the free signals room on Telegram.
Educational content, not financial advice. Trading involves risk.