Part 2: Losses and winners · Chapter 6 of 14 · 8 min

Cutting the gains

Closing before the target raises the winning share and lowers the gain. On the plan, bringing the target from 3 to 1.5 R leaves wins at 49% (from 46%) but mean R falls from +0.74 to +0.23 and the sum from +58.1 to +25.8 R; at 1 R wins are 59% and the gain +20.8 R. On 120 rules with a 3 R target, moving to 1.5 R worsens mean R in 68% of cases (−0.06 on average). Moving the stop to breakeven after +1 R costs little (−0.01 on average) and reduces the plan's drawdown from 6.1 to 4.1 R.

The temptation

In chapter 3 we saw that 66% of trades reach at least +1 R and that 41% reach 3 R. When the price is at +1.5 R the voice "cash in" is loud: a certain gain, instead of a larger uncertain one. Closing early raises the winning share and makes the journal look "nicer". Two ways of doing it:

  • Cutting the target: closing at a lower multiple of R than the plan's.
  • Moving the stop to breakeven after a certain gain (so as not to turn a win into a loss).

Cutting the target

On the plan (1.5 ATR stop), a 3 R target against lower targets. Note: nearer targets close trades earlier, and the plan opens more of them.

TargetTradesMean R ± errorSumDrawdownWinning
3 R (plan)79+0.74 ± 0.43+58.1 R6.1 R46%
2 R100+0.32 ± 0.29+31.9 R7.1 R44%
1.5 R114+0.23 ± 0.23+25.8 R6.6 R49%
1 R124+0.17 ± 0.17+20.8 R7.1 R59%
Figure 1. Cumulative R with target 3 R (pink, +58.1 R), 2 R (blue, +31.9), 1.5 R (bars, +25.8) and 1 R (dashed, +20.8). The nearer the target, the lower the curve.Data: gold, XAUUSDT perpetual future (real candles) · daily (D1) · from 15 Dec 2025 to 5 Oct 2026.
Read the chart in words

Daily gold chart with, below, four cumulative R curves: the one with the 3 R target far above the other three.

The winning share goes from 46% to 59%: the experience improves (more wins, fewer "I let it get away"). The gain shrinks to a third: from +58.1 to +20.8 R. The drawdown does not improve (from 6.1 to 6.6-7.1 R). The reason is in chapter 3: the plan lives on big wins (2.79 R on average) paid for with many small losses; cutting the wins leaves the losses the same.

The cost depends on the plan. On all the 120 rules with a 3 R target of the grid of book 12, moving to 1.5 R changes mean R by −0.06 on average, and worsens it in 68% of cases (the sum falls on average by 10.2 R). It is a smaller cost than that of the plan (−0.51): our plan was chosen, among 480, precisely because with that target it did well (book 12, chapter 4), so a cut costs it more than the average.

Moving the stop to breakeven

A common rule: after the price has gone in favour by a certain gain, the stop is moved to the entry, so the trade can no longer lose. On the plan (3 R target):

RuleTradesMean R ± errorSumDrawdownBreakeven exits
Plan (fixed stop)79+0.74 ± 0.43+58.1 R6.1 R0
Breakeven after +1 R87+0.61 ± 0.36+52.9 R4.1 R26
Breakeven after +1.5 R85+0.55 ± 0.38+46.8 R6.1 R13
Breakeven after +2 R81+0.64 ± 0.41+51.8 R6.1 R6
Figure 2. Cumulative R with the stop moved to breakeven after +1 R (blue, +52.9 R over 87 trades) against the plan (pink, +58.1 R over 79). The two curves are close; the one with the breakeven stop has a lower drawdown (4.1 against 6.1 R).Data: gold, XAUUSDT perpetual future (real candles) · daily (D1) · from 15 Dec 2025 to 5 Oct 2026.
Read the chart in words

Daily gold chart with, below, two very close cumulative R curves, the breakeven one slightly lower.

Here the cost is small: −0.13 R per trade (from +0.74 to +0.61), −5.2 R in sum, and the drawdown falls from 6.1 to 4.1 R. In 26 trades the breakeven stop makes you exit at zero (about −0.01 R, for the cost) a trade that would have ended in a loss or in a win. The winning share falls to 34%, because breakeven exits are not wins. On all the 120 rules with a 3 R target the average difference in mean R is −0.01, and it worsens in a little over half (52%), with −1.84 R of sum: practically neutral.

A reading warning: in the table the longest losing streak goes from 6 to 8 with the breakeven stop, because breakeven exits have a slightly negative result (−0.01 R, the cost) and the count considers them "losses". The journal must tell breakevens from losses.

What follows

  • Cutting the target costs a lot when the plan is made of big wins, and is paid for with a higher winning share that consoles but does not earn. Whoever feels the need to cash in early should, for consistency, choose a plan with a lower target and measure it, not cut the one with the high target.
  • The breakeven stop costs little and reduces the drawdown, but turns part of the wins into breakevens (26 out of 87) and makes the journal less gratifying. It is a management choice that can be put in the plan, with its cost.
  • What counts is the rule written beforehand: "at +1 R I move the stop" or "I never move it". The cost changes with the rule, not with the mood of the moment.

What to do with it

  1. Write what you do at +1 R (and at +1.5 R): nothing, breakeven stop, partial close. Measure the cost of each choice on your plan.
  2. If you want to cash in early, change the plan, not the trade: choose a lower target, measure its mean R and accept the winning share.
  3. Record every manual close with the reason and its distance from the target.
  4. Look at the winning share with caution: it rises when you cut, and says little about the gain.
  5. Compare with the fixed-target plan every month: how much did the deviation cost?

Procedure in four steps

  1. Compute on your plan mean R with lower targets and with the breakeven stop.
  2. Choose in writing whether and when the stop is moved or you close early.
  3. Record every manual close as a deviation.
  4. Compare every month the real sum with that of the fixed-target plan.

Exercises

Chapter exercises

1. Bringing the target from 3 R to 1.5 R the winning share rises from 46% to 49%. What happens to the plan's mean R?

2. Why is cutting the target "pleasing"?

3. On 120 rules with a 3 R target, in what share does moving to 1.5 R worsen mean R?

4. The breakeven stop after +1 R takes the drawdown from 6.1 to 4.1 R and mean R from +0.74 to +0.61. How is it read?

Have a question or want to share your exercise?

Post in the community, or join the free signals room on Telegram.

Educational content, not financial advice. Trading involves risk.