Part 2: Losses and winners · Chapter 6 of 14 · 8 min
Cutting the gains
Closing before the target raises the winning share and lowers the gain. On the plan, bringing the target from 3 to 1.5 R leaves wins at 49% (from 46%) but mean R falls from +0.74 to +0.23 and the sum from +58.1 to +25.8 R; at 1 R wins are 59% and the gain +20.8 R. On 120 rules with a 3 R target, moving to 1.5 R worsens mean R in 68% of cases (−0.06 on average). Moving the stop to breakeven after +1 R costs little (−0.01 on average) and reduces the plan's drawdown from 6.1 to 4.1 R.
The temptation
In chapter 3 we saw that 66% of trades reach at least +1 R and that 41% reach 3 R. When the price is at +1.5 R the voice "cash in" is loud: a certain gain, instead of a larger uncertain one. Closing early raises the winning share and makes the journal look "nicer". Two ways of doing it:
- Cutting the target: closing at a lower multiple of R than the plan's.
- Moving the stop to breakeven after a certain gain (so as not to turn a win into a loss).
Cutting the target
On the plan (1.5 ATR stop), a 3 R target against lower targets. Note: nearer targets close trades earlier, and the plan opens more of them.
| Target | Trades | Mean R ± error | Sum | Drawdown | Winning |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 R (plan) | 79 | +0.74 ± 0.43 | +58.1 R | 6.1 R | 46% |
| 2 R | 100 | +0.32 ± 0.29 | +31.9 R | 7.1 R | 44% |
| 1.5 R | 114 | +0.23 ± 0.23 | +25.8 R | 6.6 R | 49% |
| 1 R | 124 | +0.17 ± 0.17 | +20.8 R | 7.1 R | 59% |
Read the chart in words
Daily gold chart with, below, four cumulative R curves: the one with the 3 R target far above the other three.
The winning share goes from 46% to 59%: the experience improves (more wins, fewer "I let it get away"). The gain shrinks to a third: from +58.1 to +20.8 R. The drawdown does not improve (from 6.1 to 6.6-7.1 R). The reason is in chapter 3: the plan lives on big wins (2.79 R on average) paid for with many small losses; cutting the wins leaves the losses the same.
The cost depends on the plan. On all the 120 rules with a 3 R target of the grid of book 12, moving to 1.5 R changes mean R by −0.06 on average, and worsens it in 68% of cases (the sum falls on average by 10.2 R). It is a smaller cost than that of the plan (−0.51): our plan was chosen, among 480, precisely because with that target it did well (book 12, chapter 4), so a cut costs it more than the average.
Moving the stop to breakeven
A common rule: after the price has gone in favour by a certain gain, the stop is moved to the entry, so the trade can no longer lose. On the plan (3 R target):
| Rule | Trades | Mean R ± error | Sum | Drawdown | Breakeven exits |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Plan (fixed stop) | 79 | +0.74 ± 0.43 | +58.1 R | 6.1 R | 0 |
| Breakeven after +1 R | 87 | +0.61 ± 0.36 | +52.9 R | 4.1 R | 26 |
| Breakeven after +1.5 R | 85 | +0.55 ± 0.38 | +46.8 R | 6.1 R | 13 |
| Breakeven after +2 R | 81 | +0.64 ± 0.41 | +51.8 R | 6.1 R | 6 |
Read the chart in words
Daily gold chart with, below, two very close cumulative R curves, the breakeven one slightly lower.
Here the cost is small: −0.13 R per trade (from +0.74 to +0.61), −5.2 R in sum, and the drawdown falls from 6.1 to 4.1 R. In 26 trades the breakeven stop makes you exit at zero (about −0.01 R, for the cost) a trade that would have ended in a loss or in a win. The winning share falls to 34%, because breakeven exits are not wins. On all the 120 rules with a 3 R target the average difference in mean R is −0.01, and it worsens in a little over half (52%), with −1.84 R of sum: practically neutral.
A reading warning: in the table the longest losing streak goes from 6 to 8 with the breakeven stop, because breakeven exits have a slightly negative result (−0.01 R, the cost) and the count considers them "losses". The journal must tell breakevens from losses.
What follows
- Cutting the target costs a lot when the plan is made of big wins, and is paid for with a higher winning share that consoles but does not earn. Whoever feels the need to cash in early should, for consistency, choose a plan with a lower target and measure it, not cut the one with the high target.
- The breakeven stop costs little and reduces the drawdown, but turns part of the wins into breakevens (26 out of 87) and makes the journal less gratifying. It is a management choice that can be put in the plan, with its cost.
- What counts is the rule written beforehand: "at +1 R I move the stop" or "I never move it". The cost changes with the rule, not with the mood of the moment.
What to do with it
- Write what you do at +1 R (and at +1.5 R): nothing, breakeven stop, partial close. Measure the cost of each choice on your plan.
- If you want to cash in early, change the plan, not the trade: choose a lower target, measure its mean R and accept the winning share.
- Record every manual close with the reason and its distance from the target.
- Look at the winning share with caution: it rises when you cut, and says little about the gain.
- Compare with the fixed-target plan every month: how much did the deviation cost?
Procedure in four steps
- Compute on your plan mean R with lower targets and with the breakeven stop.
- Choose in writing whether and when the stop is moved or you close early.
- Record every manual close as a deviation.
- Compare every month the real sum with that of the fixed-target plan.
Exercises
Chapter exercises
1. Bringing the target from 3 R to 1.5 R the winning share rises from 46% to 49%. What happens to the plan's mean R?
2. Why is cutting the target "pleasing"?
3. On 120 rules with a 3 R target, in what share does moving to 1.5 R worsen mean R?
4. The breakeven stop after +1 R takes the drawdown from 6.1 to 4.1 R and mean R from +0.74 to +0.61. How is it read?
Have a question or want to share your exercise?
Post in the community, or join the free signals room on Telegram.
Educational content, not financial advice. Trading involves risk.